Measuring sustainable cities in Russia: critical analysis of key methodologies
Abstract
The paper provides insights on the critical analysis of the current methodologies of the sustainability cities measurement for the present-day Russia. Based on meta-analysis of more than 90 peer-reviewed papers published in Russian and English, we examined both authoring and corporate methodologies such as the SGM methodology for Russian sustainable cities, the environmental rating of Russian cities, and the rating of the environmental governance of the Russian cities, the environmental efficacy index and several authoring methodologies. The analysis showed that most of the calculation methods are based on quantitative (statistical) data, what is their advantage, on the one hand, making their results as objective as possible, but on the other hand, it is a disadvantage, because in connection with the delay in publication of statistics or even its absence, it does not allow the annual dynamics to observe. In addition, the difficulty in choosing the most suitable methodology lies in the significant differences in the development of large, medium and small cities in Russia, and many rating methods are developed exclusively for one of the types of cities. Authors concluded that in spite of the high level of the existing methodologies development, there was a shortage of comprehensive studies carried out in the qualitative-quantitative paradigm that would, in addition to index assessment and mathematical models generation, explain complex causal relationships and processes within a city.
Downloads
References
Yanitsky, O., & Usacheva, O. (2017). History of the "Green City" in Russia. Journal of History of Culture and Art Research, 6 (6), 125-131.
Usacheva (Basheva) O.A. (2017). Russian Concepts of Greening Cities / Russia and the World: Global Challenges and Strategies for Sociocultural Modernization. Materials of the International Scientific and Practical Conference (Moscow, October 12-13, 2017) / Executive editor A.V. Tikhonov. Moscow: FNISTS RAS, 2017. Pp. 726-732.
McKinsey on Sustainability & Resource Productivity, 2012 [Electronic resource] URL: https://www.mckinsey.com/client_service/sustainability/latest_thinking/~/
media/5E14ED58049D44148B5A47C0124A7E66.ashx
European Green City Index, Economist Intelligence Unit, 2009 [Electronic resource] URL: https://www.siemens.com/entry/cc/features/greencityindex_international/
all/en/pdf/report_en.pdf
The Urban Sustainability Index, 2010 [Electronic resource] URL: http://www.urbanchinainitiative.org/en/research/usi.html
Economist Intelligence Unit, 2016 [Electronic resource] URL: https://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2016/08/daily-chart-14
Environmental Performance Index, 2016 [Electronic resource] URL: https://epi.envirocenter.yale.edu/
The Social Progress Index, 2016 [Electronic resource] URL: http://www.socialprogressimperative.org/publication/2016-social-progress-index/
Sustainable Society Index [Electronic resource] URL: http://www.ssfindex.com/
Human Development Index [Electronic resource] URL: http://hdr.undp.org/en/content/human-development-index-hdi
Ermolaeva P.O. (2017). In the labyrinths of the «sustainable city» concepts: the meta-analysis of contemporary studies. The Turkish Online Journal of Design, Art and Communication.
Korotkov PA., Trubyanov AB. (2014). Estimation of ecological efficiency of large cities in the conditions of rapid urbanization // Scientific journal of KubSAU. №102 (08). P.1-27.
Korotkov P.A., Trubyanov A.B., Zagainova E.A., Nikonorov K.N. (2015). Analysis of the sustainability assessments on the ecological efficiency of large cities / / Economic sciences. №11. P.793-797.
Medvedeva L.N., Kozenko K.Yu., Komarova O.P. (2015). Prospects of medium-sized cities in the development of green economy // News of the complex of Nizhnevolzhsky Agrarian University: science and higher professional education. №4 (40). P.214-221.
Tretyakova E.A. (2014). Development sustainability assessment of ecological and economic systems: a dynamic method // Prediction problems. No. 4 (145). Pp. 143-154.
Bobylev S.N. (2007). Indicators of sustainable development: a regional dimension. A handbook on regional environmental policy. - M.: Acropolis, CEPR, 60 p.
Bobylev S.N., Kudryavtseva O.V., Solovyeva S.V. (2014). Indicators of sustainable development for cities // Economy of the region. No. 3. Pp. 101-110.
Rating of sustainable development of Russian cities for 2013 / LLC "Agency ES GM" [Electronic resource].URL: http://agencysgm.com/projects/SGM%20Rating2013.pdf
The rating of environmental management..., 2015 / LLC "Agency ES GM" [Electronic resource].URL: http://agencysgm.com/news/reyting-ekologicheskogo-upravleniya-gorodov-rossii/
Rating of ecological development of Russian cities in 2017 [Electronic resource].URL: https://onf.ru/sites/default/files/projects_docs/21112017.pdf
Ecological rating of subjects of the Russian Federation: Ideology, conceptual model and methodology of rating calculation [Electronic resource].URL: http://greenpatrol.ru/sites/default/files/_ppt_1_0_0.pdf
The ecological efficiency rating... 2014 [Electronic resource].URL: https://epi.envirocenter.yale.edu/