State as evolving phenomenon: Key problems and approaches
The article analyzes the fundamental issues of state evolution and typology. The authors justify that the state is an evolving phenomenon of social and legal reality. At that, it is shown that in the process of this evolution, along with the preservation of universal (essential) characteristics, conditioned by the nature and social purpose of the state, there is a modification of those properties and attributes that have a specific historical character and depend on a variety of factors that influence a state on an appropriate stage of development. The paper substantiates that the evolution of a state phenomenon must be considered in the context of general social evolution, which is, in the most general sense, the process of that intersubjective experience complication, accumulation and organization. The authors argue that any common (generic) concept of "state" is a conditional one to a certain extent, since it does not have a real ontological status, acting as the result of a series of typifications mediated by language and carried out in accordance with the relevances largely dictated by that practical life situation.
Berent M. (2000) Anthropology and the Classics: War Violence and the Stateless Polis// Classical Quarterly. Oxford,. № 50. pp. 257–289.
Boethius. (1996). Commentary on Porphyry // Boethius. "Consolation by Philosophy" and other treatises. M., pp. 31, 43.
Eisenstadt S.N. (1963).The Political Systems of Empires. New York,
Fortes M., Evans-Pritchard E.E. (1940). Introduction // African Political Systems / Ed. by M. Fortes, E.E. Evans-Pritchard. Oxford, pp. 1–23.
Guthrie H. (1960). God and History in the Old Testament. Greenwich (Conn), pp. 97—100.
Hansen M.H. (1998). Polis and the City-State: An Ancient Concept and its Modern Equivalent. Copenhagen,. pp. 14, 35–37.
Ingerflom C. (1993). Oublier l’état pour comprendre la Russie? // Revue des etudes slaves. Vol. LXVI. № 1. pp. 125–134.
KABASHEVA I.A., KHAIRULLINA A.G., I. A. RUDALEVA I.A. (2017). Analysis of scientific and technical activity resourcing in Russia, Astra Salvensis, Supplement No. 10, p. 355-365.
Kofanov L.L. (2006). The concepts res publica and civitas in the 50th book of the Justinian digest // Digestions of Justinian. V. VIII. Articles and indexes / Ed. in charge: L.L. Kofanov. M., pp. 196-204.
Le Goff J. (1964). La civilisation de l’Occident medieval. Paris: Arthaud, 692 p.
Llewellen T.C. (1983). Political Anthropology: An Introduction. 2nd ed. South Hadley.
Lyubashits, V., Mamychev, A., Uvarova, G., & Artyukhin, O. (2017). Sociocultural measurement of institutional and functional characteristics of public-power interactions. Man in India, 97(23), 461-470.
Mancuso G. (1995). Forma di stato e forma di governo nell’ esperanza constituzionale Greco-Romana. Catania, P. 72.
Manville Ph. B. (1990). The Origins of Citizenship in Ancient Athen. Princeton,. p. 6;
Osborne R. (1985). Demos: The Discovery of Classical Attika. Cambridge, P. XIV.
Post G. (1964). Studies in Medieval Legal Thought. Princeton, P. 10.
Razuvaev N.V. (2011). The evolution of the political organization of society in the context of social development // Personality. Culture. Society. Interdisciplinary scientific and practical journal of social sciences. V. XIII. Issue. 1 (61-62). pp. 253-259.
Sahlins M.D. (1960). Evolution: Specific and General // Evolution and Culture / Ed. by M.D. Sahlins and E.R. Service. Ann Arbor,. p. 37.
Schutz A. (1970). Reflections on the Problem of Relevance. Edited by Richard Zaner. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Schweitzer H.(1935). Die sogenannten Definitionen durch Abstraktion. Leipzig,
Service E.R. (1971). Primitive Social Organization. An Evolutionary Theory. New York.
Skinner K. (2002) The State // The concept of the state in four languages. p. 50.
Spiridonov L.I. (2001). Theory of State and Law.
M., pp. 30-31.
Van Creveld M. (2016). The flowering and the decay of the state. M., p. 12.
Villalobos Antúnez J.V. (2016). Hipótesis para un derecho alternativo desde la perspectiva latinoamericana. Opción, 32(13), pp. 7-10.
Ward L. F. (1883). Dynamic Sociology. New York, P. 224.
Weber M. (1930). The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism Trans. Talcott Parsons, Anthony Giddens.London; Boston : Unwin Hyman, p. 9.
Weber M. (1930). The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism., Trans. Talcott Parsons, Anthony Giddens. London, Boston : Unwin Hyman.
Will E. (1972). Le monde grec et l’Orient. Paris, T. 1. La V-eme Siecle (510—403). P. 432;
Zoltan A. (2002). To the prehistory of Russian "sovereign" // From the history of Russian culture. V. II. Book. 1. Kiev and Moscow Rus / Ed. and compiler: A.F. Litvin and F.B. Uspensky. M., p. 552.