National Identity Formation under Statelessness: Experience of Ukraine in Soviet Times

Keywords: national identity, Soviet time, statelessness, Ukrainian experience, Yu. Stupak.


The issue of national identity is multifaceted, disputable and extremely important in modern society, being one of the factors that determine its vitality. This paper presents the look at the problem from pedagogical perspective. The authors aim to explore the peculiarities of the formation of Ukrainian national identity in native intelligentsia under Ukrainian statelessness in Soviet times using the life and activity of Yurii Stupak as an example. Yurii Stupak is a notable representative of Ukrainian intelligentsia, an educator, scholar, literary studies expert, art critic, local history researcher, the author of numerous works in history of education and ethno-pedagogy. The study uses qualitative methodology and is founded on the laws and categories of scientific research. The researchers applied modern research approaches (personality oriented, cultural, personified, interdisciplinary) and methods (general scientific analysis, comparison, generalization, systematization; textual analysis, elaboration of the source base and historiographical work on the selected problem; the method of retrospective analysis). The authors have established that formation of the personality of Yurii Stupak as a teacher and scholar was influenced by numerous socio-political, socio-economic, cultural-educational and personal factors. The authors prove the decisive impact of family education and learning from nationally conscious teachers at higher education institutions as well as self-education and will for constant personal and professional development on facilitating the continuity of the process of formation of Ukrainian national identity in the native intelligentsia during the investigated period. It is confirmed that national identity does not depend on the existence of sovereign statehood, but it stimulates its revival.


Download data is not yet available.

Author Biographies

Olena Pokhilko, Sumy State University

PhD in Education, Sumy State University, Lecturer of the Chair of Language Training for Foreign Citizens, Ukraine.

Iryna Ivanova, Sumy State Pedagogical University named after A. S. Makarenko

PhD in Education, Associate Professor, Sumy State Pedagogical University named after A. S. Makarenko, Head of the Chair of Russian Language, Foreign Literature and Methods of their Teaching, Ukraine.

Daria Martynenko, Sumy State Pedagogical University

PhD in Education, Sumy State Pedagogical University named after A. S. Makarenko, Lecturer of Chair of Pedagogics, Ukraine.


Аrtiukh, V. O., Іvanushenko, G. M. & Sadivnychy, V. O. (Eds.). (2012). Dissent in Sumy region: collection of documents and materials (1955–1990). Sumy, Ukraine: «Mrіa-1»

Bakіrov, V. S. (2006). Kharkiv national university named after V. N. Karazin: timeline. Local lore [Local history], vol. 1-4, pp. 121-125.

Berezіvska, L. D. (2009). Organizational-pedagogical foundations of reforming school education in Ukraine in the XX century (PhD thesis). Institute of Pedagogy, Academy of Pedagogical Sciences of Ukraine, Kyiv, Ukraine.

Bulgakova, O. (2013). Scientific-pedagogical intelligentsia of Ukraine (mid-1950 – first half of the 1960) as an object of state policy. In V. M. Danylenko (Ed.). Ukraine in the 20th century: culture, ideology, politics: collection of works (V. 18, p. 232-245). Kyiv, Ukraine: Nat. acad. Sciences of Ukraine, Institute of History of Ukraine.

Bystra, M. (2009). Scientific-pedagogical intelligentsia of the UkrSSR in 1943-1945: Life and work in the war conditions. Scientific letters of Ternopil State University named after Volodymyr Gnatiuk. Series: history, vol. 2, pp. 181-188

Cheremska, O. (2016) Origins of Kharkiv philological school and Potebnia’s national-language traditions. Ukrainska mova, vol. 2, pp. 92-111

Danko, M. (1971). Spring furrows of the researcher. Creative portraits: Yu. P. Stupak. Leninsk is true, 9, June.

Gomotiuk, O. (2013). Controversy of the policy of “Ukrainization” and its influence on the development of Ukrainian studies. Retrieved from:

Kashaba, O. Yu. (2010). Contribution of educators of the Kharkiv Region to the development of local history studies in the 20-s and early 30-s of the XX century. Kharkіv, Ukraine: Hark. nat. un-t.

Korzh, L. V. (1999). History of formation and development of the Sumy State Pedagogical University named after A. S. Makarenko. Sumy, Ukraine: SumDPU.

Kostytski, M. V. (2016). Psychological, legal and political aspects of the introduction of Ukrainian language as a state language. Legal Psychology, vol. 2 (19), pp. 9-19

Makarova, T. (2019). Concept «identity» in antique philosophical discourse. Amazonia Investiga, vol. 8, num. 19, pp. 207–211

Mandebura, O. S. (2011). Mykola Sumtsov and problems of socio-cultural identity. Кyiv, Ukraine: Institute of Political and Ethnonational Studies.

Marochko, V. & Hіllіg, G. (2003). Repressed teachers of Ukraine: victims of political terror (1929–1941). Kyiv, Ukraine:

Naukovyi svіt. Misinkevych, L. L. (2003). Rehabilitation of the scientific and creative intelligentsia in the second half of the 50-ies – 60-ies of the 20th century. In P. T. Tronko (Ed.). History of Ukraine. Little-known names, events, facts: a collection of articles (V. 22–23, p. 374–389). Kyiv, Ukraine: Nat. acad. Sciences of Ukraine, Institute of History of Ukraine.

Pantiuk, M. P. (2011). Preparation of the future teacher for educational work in the national pedagogy of the XX century. (PhD thesis in Education). Drogob. State Ped. Univ. I. Franko, Drohobych, Ukraine.

Pitov, V. I. (Еds.). (1967). Higher school of the Ukrainian SSR for 50 years (1917–1967). (V. 1: 1917–1945 years). Kyiv, Ukraine: Editorial of Kyiv University.

Pohіlko, O. V. (2017). Yurii Petrovych (1911–1979): catalog of works. Sumy, Ukraine: IE Tsioma S. P.
Potapchuk, T. (2011). Formation of the national identity. Retrieved from: (in Ukrainian).

Prokop, I. S. (2007). Historical and Pedagogical Analysis of the Purpose of Education in the Soviet School of the 1950–1980’s. Scientific Herald of Chernihiv University. Series: Pedagogy and Psychology, vol. 342, pp. 137-149.

Rabchenko, O. L. (1997). Kharkiv institute of public education named after O. Potebnia (1921–1930). (Abstract of PhD thesis in History). Dnipropetrovsk. State Un-t., Dnіpropetrovsk, Ukraine.

Rodríguez, E., Martínez, I. (2016). La educación patrimonial. Consideraciones sobre su contribución al proceso de educación. Amazonia Investiga, vol. 5, num. 9, pp. 82–90

Sambros, Yu. (1988). Stages: My Way to Communism. [Without a place of publication], Ukraine: Suchasnіst

Sukhomlynska, O. (2012). In the search of real. In V. Suhomlynsky. To Children I Give My Heart (pp. 5–23). Kyiv, Ukraine: Аkta.

Sukhomlynska, O. V. (2009). Pedagogical ideal through the prism of theories of morality. Pedagogical sciences, vol. 1, pp. 5-15

Sukhomlynsky, V. O. (1976). Selected works. (V. 1–5). Kyiv, Ukraine: Radianska school.

Tatanenko, T. M. (2010). Regional identity in the political space of Ukraine. Gіleya: scientific herald, vol. 30.

Vertіi, O. (1996). Island of the Ukrainian spirit. 85 years since the birth of Yurii Petrovych Stupak. Chervonyi promіn, 27 december.

Yarmachenko, M. D. (Eds.). (1996). Institute of Pedagogics of Academy of Pedagogical Sciences 70-year anniversary. Kyiv, Ukraine: Pedagogical thought.
How to Cite
Pokhilko, O., Ivanova, I., & Martynenko, D. (2020). National Identity Formation under Statelessness: Experience of Ukraine in Soviet Times. Amazonia Investiga, 9(32), 70-80.