Social legal state as a constitutional value
In the 21st century, the discussion of constitutional values from the standpoint of designating arbitrary value judgments faced by the legislator of constitutional documents becomes quite relevant. Moreover, the fundamental constitutional principles, rights and obligations of each citizen are appropriately consolidated. Therefore, if we are talking about constitutional values, we take for granted a definite frame of reference as to what belongs to these values and, above all, we are talking about a socially-legal state as a constitutional value, within the framework of which the very fundamental civil public rights and obligations. However, the problems associated with the definition of the state as a socio-legal one in the context of constitutional values have by no means been resolved to date. In reality, today there is only a vague structure of what can legally be called "constitutional."Each constituent convention can distinguish certain aspects from existing values that can be recognized as “constitutional”. Consequently, the structure of the socio-legal state and its definition as a constitutional value as a result of constitutional choice are very different in each individual state. The point is not only to “write” the new constitution, to fix the fundamental norms, principles, and also rights and obligations in it, but to ensure that all this is done in reality.Constitutional provisions are always interpreted in accordance with the spirit of the times, the dominant idea of the times, so that the fundamental rights and requirements of the democratic process are strikingly different in a particular time period. Therefore, we need a certain “coordinate system” that gives reason to consider the state of social and legal due to certain provisions. A practice without a system of constitutional values constitutional could cast doubt on the preference of one particular value and law in a biased way and turn them into something completely opposite, in the legitimization of injustice in the name of constitutional law. This will be the case if the value of democracy justifies a dictatorship based on one-sided general elections, or if the values of equality are realized by state planning, which guarantees equal results, rejecting human freedom. In this study, the author analyzes the state legal and constitutional foundations of the formation and development of a socio-legal state and concludes that only the constitutional consolidation of the basic social privileges of a citizen will make it possible to determine the state as constitutional value.
Acosta Fierro, L. (2018). La ciudadanía en el contexto de la Constitución de la República Bolivariana de Venezuela. Revista de la Universidad del Zulia, No. 25 (9), 27-40. https://produccioncientificaluz.org/index.php/rluz/article/view/29738
Afanasyeva A.A. (2016). To the question of the concept of constitutional restrictions on human rights in the Russian Federation and EU countries. Bulletin of the Saratov State Law Academy. No. 2 (109). P121-124.
Atagimova E.I. (2013). The formation of a socially developed personality as a necessary prerequisite for the development of the rule of law. Jurisprudence and the development of Russian legislation in modernization: proceedings of the International Scientific Conference. P.17-22.
Bychkov D.G., Feoktistova O.A., Andreeva E.I. (2017). Social protection and statistics: a comparative analysis of Russian and international accounting practices in an attempt to assess the effectiveness of budgetary measures in the field of social protection of the population. Accounting in budget and non-profit organizations. Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/sotsialnaya-zaschita-i-statistika-sopostavitelnyy-analiz-rossiyskoy-i-mezhdunarodnoy-praktiki-ucheta-v-popytke-otsenit-effektivnost-2 (accessed 26 November 2019)
Farber I.E. (1979). Soviet state law. Saratov. P. 71.
Marshall, Thomas Humphrey (1950). Citizenship and Social Class: And Other Essays. Cambridge: University Press.
Novikov M.V. (2013). Clerical state and church. Relations between church and state in Israel and in neighboring countries. Dis. Cand. P. 35.
Oleinikova E.G. (2014). Fundamentals of the welfare state. Volgograd branch of FSBEI HPE "Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration". Available at: https://vlgr.ranepa.ru/files/izd/elizd/ (accessed September 30, 2019).
Pleshakov A.P. (2004). Constitutional imperatives of the Russian socio-legal statehood // Constitution of the Russian Federation and modern legislation: problems of implementation and development trends (On the 10th anniversary of the Constitution of Russia). International Scientific and Practical Conference (October 1 - 3, 2003).. S. 4-6.
Rodionova O.V. (2015). Problems of development of the theory and practice of the modern social state // Lex Russica. No. 1. P.28-40.
Rumyantsev O.G. (2007). New Constitution for Russia: our approaches // From the history of the creation of the Constitution of the Russian Federation. Constitutional Commission: transcripts, materials, documents (1990-1993): in 6 vol. T. 1: 1990 / under the general. ed. O.G. Rumyantsev. M., 2007.S. 840.
Tugarinov V.P. (1960). On the values of life and culture. Leningrad.P. 3
Vitruk N.V. (2009). The Constitution of the Russian Federation as a value and constitutional values. Materials of a scientific and practical conference dedicated to the 15th anniversary of the Constitution of the Russian Federation and the 60th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (St. Petersburg, November 13-14, 2008). Moscow. P. 270.
Zhinkin S.A., Kovtun Z.L. (2015). On the social and value foundations of the implementation of legal regulation. North Caucasian Legal Bulletin. No. 4. P.27-29.