Theoretical approaches to delimiting the jurisdiction of commercial, civil and administrative courts
Keywords:
jurisdiction, civil jurisdiction, administrative jurisdiction, economic jurisdiction, court.
Abstract
The judiciary is called upon to ensure justice, ensuring human rights and freedoms, and balancing private and public interests. In this aspect, a significant role is played by the correct choice of the court that is authorized to consider a case. This problem is acute in the separation of jurisdiction of commercial, civil and administrative proceedings. In view of this, it is vital to study theoretical approaches to delimiting the jurisdiction of commercial, civil and administrative courts. The aim of the work is to analyze theoretical approaches and problematic issues regarding the delimitation of jurisdiction of commercial, civil and administrative courts. The methodology of the study included such methods as comparison, analogy, generalization, systemic, structural-functional method, method of analysis and synthesis. The study of theoretical approaches to the delimitation of jurisdiction of commercial, civil and administrative courts allowed to analyze the characteristics of each of the jurisdictions. It is also remarked that determining the jurisdiction of the dispute remains a rather difficult problem for the practice of law enforcement, due not only to imperfect legislation, but also to existing dogmas in science and practice. Also, the problem arises in determining the criteria for delimitation of jurisdiction.
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Bobkova, A., & Novoshytska, V. (2017). Jurisdiction of commercial courts. Law of Ukraine, 9, 83-93. Recovered from https://rd.ua/storage/attachments/Бобкова_Новошицька_2017_Юрисдикція%20господарських%20судів.pdf
Bryntsev, O.V. (2007). Delimitation of the competence of administrative and commercial courts: problems and prospects. Kharkiv: Law. Recovered from https://library.nlu.edu.ua/BIBLIOTEKA/SAIT/FAKULTET%208/2/BrincMono.pdf
Golubeva, E.A. (2022). Problems of jurisdiction in commercial litigation. Science, trends and perspectives of development, 7, 76-78. Recovered from https://eu-conf.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/SCIENCE-TRENDS-AND-PERSPECTIVES-OF-DEVELOPMENT.pdf#page=77
Karayanide, M. (2016). Adjudicative Jurisdiction in Civil and Commercial Matters in Russia: Analysis and Commentary. The American Journal of Comparative Law, 64, 981-1017. Recovered from https://www.jstor.org/stable/26425482
Kataeva, E.V. (2015). Theoretical and practical problems of distinguishing administrative jurisdiction from civil. Science and Law Enforcement, 3, 48-56. Recovered from http://naukaipravoohorona.com/journal/ukr/2015_3.pdf#page=48
Knyazev, V. (2020). A judge of the Supreme Court spoke about the criteria for delimitation of judicial jurisdiction. Law and Business, 21, 1-5. Recovered from https://zib.com.ua/ua/142344.html
Kolomoiets, T., & Lyutikov, P. (2009). Problems of legal delimitation of administrative and economic jurisdiction: analysis of the preconditions of origin and possible ways to solve them. Law of Ukraine, 10, 175-181.
Kravchuk, V.M. (2012). Legal bases of jurisdiction of courts in Ukraine: theory and practice. Legal science, 6, 110-130. Recovered from https://legal.nam.edu.ua/journal/n-6-2012.pdf#page=110
Malolitneva, V.K. (2019). Problems of delimitation of economic and administrative judicial jurisdictions in cases of public procurement. Law and society, 4, 104-112. Recovered from http://pravoisuspilstvo.org.ua/archive/2019/4_2019/17.pdf
Michaels, R. (2006). Two Paradigms of Jurisdiction. Michigan Journal of International Law, 27, 1003-1069. Recovered from https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/232699756.pdf
Mykolenko, I.O. (2018). Problems of determining the jurisdiction of the court. Odesa: Phoenix. Recovered from http://dspace.onu.edu.ua:8080/handle/123456789/14834
Negoda, O. (2017.) Delimitation of judicial jurisdictions in cases of protection of the rights and legitimate interests of the child (based on case law). Entrepreneurship, economy and law, 12, 50-53. Recovered from http://pgp-journal.kiev.ua/archive/2017/12/12.pdf
Obrizko, I.M. (2011). Problems of jurisdiction of administrative courts and the principle of specialization in the judicial system. Economic and Legal Scientific and Practical Journal, 3-4, 46-52. Recovered from www.kostytsky.com.ua/upload/doc/msb/msb-3-4-2011.pdf#page=46
Reznikov, V. (2014). Jurisdiction of commercial courts of Ukraine: problems of theory and practice. Bulletin of the Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, 1, 24-32.
Romanyuk, J., & Maistrenko, L. (2017). Problems of delimitation of administrative and civil judicial jurisdictions in land disputes: prospects for resolution due to the update of procedural legislation. Law of Ukraine, 8, 83-99. Recovered from https://rd.ua/storage/lessons/38/789.Романюк%20Я.,%20Майстренко%20Л.-83-99.pdf
Ryzhenko, N., & Korolyova, O. (2020). General provisions on civil jurisdiction. Young scholars, 10(86), 355-361.
Sambir, O.E. (2012). Some problems of delimitation of civil, administrative and economic jurisdictions. University scientific notes, 3(43), 117-124. Recovered from http://old.univer.km.ua/statti/8.sambir_o._ye._okremi_pytannya_rozmezhuvannya_
tsyvil_noyi,_administratyvnoyi_ta_hospodars_koyi_yurysdyktsiy.pdf
Sereda, V. (2020). Delimitation of court jurisdiction and practice of resolving jurisdictional disputes. AO EQUITY, 32, 1-6. Recovered from https://equity.law/images/publication/news_name/rozmeguvannya-yurisdiktsii-sudiv-i-praktika-virishennya-yurisdiktsiinih.pdf
Sidey, J. (2018). Distinguishing administrative jurisdiction from other types of jurisdiction in the field of judicial competence. Entrepreneurship, economy and law, 6, 196-200. Recovered from http://www.pgp-journal.kiev.ua/archive/2018/6/36.pdf
Udod, M.V., & Pirogov, V.S. (2017). On the issue of determining the criteria of jurisdiction of administrative courts for the consideration of public law disputes. Sociology of law, 3-4, 129-134. Recovered from https://library.vspu.net/bitstream/handle/123456789/9307/Udod_On%20the%
20issue%20of%20determining%20the%20criteria%20of%20jurisdiction.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
Viktorchuk, M. (2016). Delimitation of jurisdiction of administrative and commercial courts in Ukraine. Scientific Journal of the National Academy of the Prosecutor of Ukraine, 3, 49-57. Recovered from www.chasopysnapu.gp.gov.ua/ua/pdf/11-2016/viktorchuk.pdf
Yurynets, Yu. L. (2012). Problems of distinguishing between public and private components of litigation in the field of protection of cultural rights of citizens. University scientific notes, 4(44), 309-315.
Zhushman, M.V. (2016). On the issue of delimitation of jurisdiction of courts to appeal against decisions of state registrars. Comparative and analytical law, 4, 72-75. Recovered from http://pap-journal.in.ua/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/4_2016.pdf#page=72
Bryntsev, O.V. (2007). Delimitation of the competence of administrative and commercial courts: problems and prospects. Kharkiv: Law. Recovered from https://library.nlu.edu.ua/BIBLIOTEKA/SAIT/FAKULTET%208/2/BrincMono.pdf
Golubeva, E.A. (2022). Problems of jurisdiction in commercial litigation. Science, trends and perspectives of development, 7, 76-78. Recovered from https://eu-conf.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/SCIENCE-TRENDS-AND-PERSPECTIVES-OF-DEVELOPMENT.pdf#page=77
Karayanide, M. (2016). Adjudicative Jurisdiction in Civil and Commercial Matters in Russia: Analysis and Commentary. The American Journal of Comparative Law, 64, 981-1017. Recovered from https://www.jstor.org/stable/26425482
Kataeva, E.V. (2015). Theoretical and practical problems of distinguishing administrative jurisdiction from civil. Science and Law Enforcement, 3, 48-56. Recovered from http://naukaipravoohorona.com/journal/ukr/2015_3.pdf#page=48
Knyazev, V. (2020). A judge of the Supreme Court spoke about the criteria for delimitation of judicial jurisdiction. Law and Business, 21, 1-5. Recovered from https://zib.com.ua/ua/142344.html
Kolomoiets, T., & Lyutikov, P. (2009). Problems of legal delimitation of administrative and economic jurisdiction: analysis of the preconditions of origin and possible ways to solve them. Law of Ukraine, 10, 175-181.
Kravchuk, V.M. (2012). Legal bases of jurisdiction of courts in Ukraine: theory and practice. Legal science, 6, 110-130. Recovered from https://legal.nam.edu.ua/journal/n-6-2012.pdf#page=110
Malolitneva, V.K. (2019). Problems of delimitation of economic and administrative judicial jurisdictions in cases of public procurement. Law and society, 4, 104-112. Recovered from http://pravoisuspilstvo.org.ua/archive/2019/4_2019/17.pdf
Michaels, R. (2006). Two Paradigms of Jurisdiction. Michigan Journal of International Law, 27, 1003-1069. Recovered from https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/232699756.pdf
Mykolenko, I.O. (2018). Problems of determining the jurisdiction of the court. Odesa: Phoenix. Recovered from http://dspace.onu.edu.ua:8080/handle/123456789/14834
Negoda, O. (2017.) Delimitation of judicial jurisdictions in cases of protection of the rights and legitimate interests of the child (based on case law). Entrepreneurship, economy and law, 12, 50-53. Recovered from http://pgp-journal.kiev.ua/archive/2017/12/12.pdf
Obrizko, I.M. (2011). Problems of jurisdiction of administrative courts and the principle of specialization in the judicial system. Economic and Legal Scientific and Practical Journal, 3-4, 46-52. Recovered from www.kostytsky.com.ua/upload/doc/msb/msb-3-4-2011.pdf#page=46
Reznikov, V. (2014). Jurisdiction of commercial courts of Ukraine: problems of theory and practice. Bulletin of the Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, 1, 24-32.
Romanyuk, J., & Maistrenko, L. (2017). Problems of delimitation of administrative and civil judicial jurisdictions in land disputes: prospects for resolution due to the update of procedural legislation. Law of Ukraine, 8, 83-99. Recovered from https://rd.ua/storage/lessons/38/789.Романюк%20Я.,%20Майстренко%20Л.-83-99.pdf
Ryzhenko, N., & Korolyova, O. (2020). General provisions on civil jurisdiction. Young scholars, 10(86), 355-361.
Sambir, O.E. (2012). Some problems of delimitation of civil, administrative and economic jurisdictions. University scientific notes, 3(43), 117-124. Recovered from http://old.univer.km.ua/statti/8.sambir_o._ye._okremi_pytannya_rozmezhuvannya_
tsyvil_noyi,_administratyvnoyi_ta_hospodars_koyi_yurysdyktsiy.pdf
Sereda, V. (2020). Delimitation of court jurisdiction and practice of resolving jurisdictional disputes. AO EQUITY, 32, 1-6. Recovered from https://equity.law/images/publication/news_name/rozmeguvannya-yurisdiktsii-sudiv-i-praktika-virishennya-yurisdiktsiinih.pdf
Sidey, J. (2018). Distinguishing administrative jurisdiction from other types of jurisdiction in the field of judicial competence. Entrepreneurship, economy and law, 6, 196-200. Recovered from http://www.pgp-journal.kiev.ua/archive/2018/6/36.pdf
Udod, M.V., & Pirogov, V.S. (2017). On the issue of determining the criteria of jurisdiction of administrative courts for the consideration of public law disputes. Sociology of law, 3-4, 129-134. Recovered from https://library.vspu.net/bitstream/handle/123456789/9307/Udod_On%20the%
20issue%20of%20determining%20the%20criteria%20of%20jurisdiction.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
Viktorchuk, M. (2016). Delimitation of jurisdiction of administrative and commercial courts in Ukraine. Scientific Journal of the National Academy of the Prosecutor of Ukraine, 3, 49-57. Recovered from www.chasopysnapu.gp.gov.ua/ua/pdf/11-2016/viktorchuk.pdf
Yurynets, Yu. L. (2012). Problems of distinguishing between public and private components of litigation in the field of protection of cultural rights of citizens. University scientific notes, 4(44), 309-315.
Zhushman, M.V. (2016). On the issue of delimitation of jurisdiction of courts to appeal against decisions of state registrars. Comparative and analytical law, 4, 72-75. Recovered from http://pap-journal.in.ua/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/4_2016.pdf#page=72
Published
2022-05-29
How to Cite
Demchenko, S., Kostruba, A., Melekh, B., Bolokan, I., & Melnychuk, O. (2022). Theoretical approaches to delimiting the jurisdiction of commercial, civil and administrative courts. Amazonia Investiga, 11(52), 204-211. https://doi.org/10.34069/AI/2022.52.04.22
Issue
Section
Articles
.gif)
