The optimality of the option of abolishing serfdom in Russia, implemented in 1861
Abstract
The article discusses the controversial issues related to the abolition of serfdom in Russia in 1861: its causes, features of preparation and implementation. The authors focus on the question of whether the implemented version of the abolition of serfdom in Russia was optimal. For this purpose, a comparative analysis of the abolition of serfdom in Russia is carried out with similar reforms in European countries, which could serve as a reference point, primarily in Austria and Prussia. It is concluded that the peasant reform in Russia in 1861 (in the final version) was carried out primarily in the interests of the state and not of individual social groups (landowners and peasants). It is the state that has benefited most from the implementation of this particular version of the reform, both financially and politically. Among the losers there were both peasants (to a greater extent) and landowners (to a lesser extent). The main thing was that the reform provoked the problem of the lack of land of the majority of peasants, which in the future became one of the main reasons for the social explosion and revolutions at the beginning of the XX century.
Downloads
References
Druzhinin, N.M. (1946). State peasants and the reform of P.D. Kiseleva. Volume 1. Moscow: USSR Academy of Sciences.
Druzhinin, N.M. (1958). State peasants and the reform of P.D. Kiseleva. Volume 2. Moscow: USSR Academy of Sciences.
Druzhinin, N.M. (1978). Russian village at the turn of 1861-1881. Мoscow: Science. Retrieved at https://search.rsl.ru/ru/record/01007776602
Emmons, T. (1968). The Russian Landed Gentry and the Peasant Emancipation of 1861. Cambridge: University Press.
Epshtein, A.D. (1961). History of Germany from the Late Middle Ages to the Revolution of 1848. Moscow: Institute of International Relations.
Field, D. (1976). The End of Serfdom. Nobility and Bureaucracy in Russia, 1855-1861. Harvard: University Press.
Field, D. (1992). 1861: "jubilee year". Great reforms in Russia 1856-1874. B. m: National Electronic Library, 73-89. Retrieved at https://rusneb.ru/catalog/000202_000006_875551/
Gotrell, P. (1992). The significance of the Great Reforms in the history of the Russian economy. Great reforms in Russia 1856-1874. B. m: National Electronic Library, 106-125. Retrieved at https://rusneb.ru/catalog/000202_000006_876072/
Hawk, S. (1992) Banking Crisis, Peasant Reform and Buyout Operation in Russia. 1857-1861. Great reforms in Russia 1856-1874. B. m: National Electronic Library, 90-105. Retrieved at https://rusneb.ru/catalog/000202_000006_871334/
Khoros, V.G. (1994). Russian history in comparative coverage. Мoscow: Aspect press. Retrieved at https://rusneb.ru/catalog/000202_000006_154711/
Khristoforov, I.A. (2016). Great reforms: origins, context, results. Reforms in Russia from ancient times to the end of the 20th century. M.: Editor "Political Encyclopedia", 14-183. Retrieved at https://publications.hse.ru/chapters/198254741
Kodan, S.V. (2006). Complete collection of laws of the Russian Empire (to the 175th anniversary of the publication). Russian Legal Journal, 1, 145-149.
Litvak, B.G. (1991). The coup of 1861 in Russia: why the reformist alternative was not realized. Moscow: Politizdat. Retrieved at https://rusneb.ru/catalog/010003_000061_cbfe72b83ba6044db90ee4e2bbcd68a9/
Mironenko, S.V. (1989). Autocracy and Reforms: Political Struggle in Russia at the Beginning of the 19th Century. Moscow: Science». 1989.
Mitrofanov, P.P. (2003). History of Austria from ancient times to 1792. Moscow: State Public Historical Library.
Safonov, M.M. (1988). The problem of reforms in the government policy of Russia at the turn of the 18th - 19th centuries. Leningrad: Science.
Zakharov, V. Y., Volkov, V. A., Ivanova, A. N., & Shkarubo, S. N. (2021). Discussion Aspects of the Establishment and Development of Serfdom in Russia (to the 160th Anniversary of the Peasant Reform of 1861). Bylye Gody, 16(1), 253-261.
Zakharov, V.Yu. (2017). Russian and foreign constitutionalism of the late 18th - 1st quarter of the 19th centuries: the experience of comparative historical analysis. Part 2. Moscow: Prometey. Retrieved at https://avidreaders.ru/book/rossiyskiy-i-zarubezhnyy-konstitucionalizm-konca-xviii-1.html
Zakharova, L.G. (1984). Autocracy and the abolition of serfdom in Russia. 1856-1861. Moscow: Moscow State University.
Zakharova, L.G. (2011). Alexander II and the abolition of serfdom in Russia. Мoscow: Rosspen.
Zayonchkovsky, P.A. (1968). Abolition of serfdom in Russia. 3rd edition, revised and enlarged. Moscow: Prosveshcheniye. Retrieved at https://www.hse.ru/data/2012/09/23/1245663099/Зайончковский%20П.А.-Отмена%20крепостного%20права%20в%20России.1968..pdf
.gif)
