134
www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
DOI: https://doi.org/10.34069/AI/2023.63.03.12
How to Cite:
Shareef, L.A. (2023). Perceptions of EFL students on e-book based extensive reading at a tertiary level. Amazonia Investiga, 12(63),
134-147. https://doi.org/10.34069/AI/2023.63.03.12
Perceptions of EFL students on e-book based extensive reading at a
tertiary level
Yüksek Öğretim EFL Öğrencilerinin E-Kitap Tabanlı Kapsamlı Okumaya İlişkin Algıları
Received: January 22, 2023 Accepted: March 30, 2023
Written by:
Liva Adil Shareef1
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6485-5911
Abstract
Printed reading texts have been transformed
drastically which allows readers to read books in an
electronic format flexibly. Reading e-books
extensively has received much attention globally
thanks to their advantages such as portability,
convenience and affordability. Likewise, the
popularity of extensive reading programs has
increased dramatically. Correspondingly, the
number of publications related to e-books and
extensive reading has risen tremendously which has
urged the researcher to combine both in a single
study. In this respect, the current study was
conducted to pinpoint the perceptions of students
who joined an e-book based extensive reading
program at TISHK International University within
2022-2023 Academic Year in Erbil, Iraq. 50
freshman students were chosen by adopting
convenience sampling method, and the data were
collected via an extensive questionnaire, a survey
and interview. The data collection process which
included the instruments of a mixed methods design
within 11 weeks through SPSS 23 and NVivo
revealed that e-book based extensive reading
improved students’ performance, increased their
motivation, facilitated overcoming language
learning anxiety and changed overall attitudes
towards learning English with reading e-books
extensively. The findings of this study can have
some implications for researchers who are planning
to conduct an e-book-based ER instruction at their
institutions.
Keywords: Extensive reading, IELTS Speaking
Test, self-confidence, attitudes towards learning
English.
1
Ma, Assistant Lecturer, English Language Teaching Department, Faculty of Education, Tishk International University, Erbil/Iraq.
Shareef, L.A. / Volume 12 - Issue 63: 134-147 / March, 2023
Volume 12 - Issue 63
/ March 2023
135
http:// www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
Introduction
Learning a language is related to effective
communication. Therefore, proficiency
necessitates accuracy and facility (Daskan &
Yildiz, 2020). In this context, reading plays an
indispensable role in people’s lives, so
reflections of reading can be observed at different
stages of lives. Mastering reading by following
proven techniques is essential to unlock the full
potential. Reading ability cannot be
underestimated as having endeavors to decode
words because reading is an active process that
requires the learners to integrate six essential
elements into their learning environments
successfully. These elements include oral
language growth, phonemic awareness, phonics,
vocabulary, fluency and comprehension, which
can serve as a milestone in learners’ lives (Kumar
& Palukuri, 2022). The learners who are
equipped with these elements are expected to
master other vital 21st-century skills such as
information, digital, media and financial literacy
without having much difficulty. Likewise, the
learners who have mastered reading and other
21st-century skills can earn more dignity in
society (Kara & Yildiz, 2022; Ulker et al., 2021).
To illustrate, a good pilot who keeps regularly
can develop problem-solving skills to be used in
an emergency while flying. In addition, a
journalist who is familiar with current news by
following various websites can be distinguished
from others in terms of having accurate and
updated information. Moreover, a software
engineer who catches up with the latest
developments in computer science can grab the
opportunities to make a difference in the field.
After that, a visionary farmer who reads
frequently to be knowledgeable about the latest
proven techniques on agriculture can be a role
model for others. Similarly, an educator who
reads on a daily basis to fill the knowledge gaps
can earn the respect of other educators and
revolutionize education to a large extent. It can
be stated that reading helps individuals to unlock
their full potentials regardless of their
occupations.
Extensive reading (ER hereafter) is a promising
approach to second language learning which
highlights granting freedom to the readers about
the content, duration and genres. In addition, it
prioritizes getting pleasure and increasing
knowledge rather than sticking to certain
activities and forms in English. Therefore,
language learning effectively depends on learner
autonomy. Language learners must be self-
directed (Yildiz & Yucedal, 2020). In this
regard, it differentiates from other approaches
because learners can actively construct their
knowledge and progress accordingly. According
to Robb and Kano (2013), implementing an ER
based instruction at educational institutions
offers several benefits such as increasing word
power, developing reading fluency, figuring out
grammar patterns, incidentally, learning various
collocations and enhancing overall
comprehension skills. The learners who have
improved their skills considerably through ER
can also have certain advantages in other subjects
because they can identify, comprehend and make
interpretations easily while reading texts. In
addition, teachers are encouraged to enrich their
classes with supplementary activities in line with
modern teaching methodologies, so ER can be of
greatest importance to change learning
atmosphere positively (Celik, 2018). Thanks to
the increased popularity of ER globally, several
prominent publishers such as Oxford, Penguin,
Cambridge and Pearson have been increasing the
number of publications in various stages to
welcome all learners and allow them to progress
gradually.
Traditional teaching practices have transformed
tremendously thanks to the advent of web-
enhanced tools in education. Web-enhanced
tools such as YouTube, Zoom, Flickr, Zip Grade,
Kahoot, Padlet have contributed significantly to
increase the engagement of the students in
classes. In the same vein, the practices of reading
have been affected from this modification as
well. E-books have been receiving much
attention as they offer numerous advantages for
readers and teachers (Abdulrahman & Kara,
2023). E-book is an electronic version of the
traditional book which allows readers to read on
the internet through their mobile devices such as
laptops, cell phones, tablets and PDAs. Reading
books online is flexible because readers can read
with their readily available mobile technologies
conveniently. In addition, they can zoom in and
out to focus on certain points, bookmark and save
the page to be continued later. In addition, they
can install an e-dictionary and figure out the
meaning of any unknown word instantly. After
that, mobile technologies are at the heart of
students’ lives, so they can find more common
grounds if they read the books with them.
Subsequently, they can improve other skills
while reading electronically because e-books are
mostly accompanied by audio-tracks or
illustrated videos. Readers can improve their
listening and pronunciation as well. On the other
hand, it has some negative implications which
need to be handled wisely to increase the
136
www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
satisfaction rate of the students. To illustrate,
distractibility, increasing costs, limited battery
life, eye fatigue and losing the respect for reading
on the paper need to be considered and fixed, so
readers can develop good habits towards reading
books electronically (Fraser & Abbot, 2016). In
addition, balancing the time is fundamental while
implementing an e-book-based instruction
because reading on paper is the standard globally
despite some advancements in e-book
technologies. Readers can easily feel
demotivated in their classes where they are
exposed to traditional instruction including
reading paper-based books if e-book sessions last
longer than pedagogically advised time. It can be
argued that e-book-based ER can help students
develop their linguistic competence if certain
measures are taken to implement it in a
professional manner.
Purpose of the Study and Research Questions
The research questions of the study were:
This study investigated the perceptions of
students on an e-book-based ER program. In this
regard, the research questions were formulated to
be explored in the survey, questionnaire and the
interview.
Does e-book-based ER program increase
students’ motivation to read more
ambitiously?
Does e-book-based ER program enhance
students’ performance in classes?
Does e-book-based ER program affect their
overall attitudes towards learning English?
Significance of the Study
Extensive reading programs have been
implemented at many educational institutions.
Once the published studies have been examined,
it has been observed that accessing to a wide
range of paper-based books has been one of the
most chronic problems suffered by the
researchers. In the same vein, the cost and unable
to highlight certain points electronically or use e-
dictionaries have been cited as other weaknesses
of extensive reading. In addition, it has been
scanned that the number of publications on e-
book-based extensive reading has been limited
with a few studies, so this study was conducted
by combining extensive reading with e-book
initiatives to measure the effects of it on students
motivation, performance and overall attitudes at
a tertiary level in Iraq context. However, it is rare
to encounter highly motivated and focused
students, as most students are preoccupied with
their untouchable social media accounts, which
tends to transform students into introverts. Still,
this condition can be beneficial in leading
students to read online (Yildiz, 2019).
Literature Review
Extensive reading programs have been prevalent
in different versions on a global scale as it allows
more freedom to readers about the content,
duration and level. Another intriguing point of
ER is that readers join reading activities to derive
pleasure rather than being forced to take the
exams upon reading the book (Day, 2018). There
are some theoretical underpinnings of ER, so its
popularity has been increasing in the last two
decades. For example, Krashen’s five hypothesis
which are natural order, acquisition, monitor,
input and affective filter can be noticed clearly in
ER activities. Krashen (1992) puts forward the
idea that learners can learn well if activities are
ordered in a logical order where the items to be
learned should be neither too easy nor too
difficult. In other words, learning goals should be
in line with learners’ current levels. Krashen
(1983) also postulates that learners with a high
degree of motivation, self-esteem and a low level
of anxiety progress faster than others who have
less motivation, self-respect and more anxiety. In
addition, Vygotsky’s (2011) ZPD was in line
with ER programs because ZPD urges the
learners to improve their skills with the guidance
of an expert which are ensured with a teacher in
ER programs. In other words, learners can
embark on a learning journey with their teachers,
so they can enhance their performance
correspondingly in ER programs. Likewise, ER
programs are consistent with John Dewey’s
(1938) theory of learning which highlights that
students learn well when they join, discuss,
brainstorm, experience, share, evaluate and apply
actively. ER programs offer a welcoming
learning atmosphere to read, exchange their
ideas, improve critical thinking skills and learn
some valuable lessons from the books to be used
in social life.
Different versions of ER programs can include
paper-based, online or hybrid which have certain
advantages and disadvantages. A number of
scholars postulated that extensive reading is a
more fruitful approach than others in terms of
improving cognitive, affective and psychomotor
domain of learning (Horst, 2005), lexical
expansion (Nation, 2009), reading
comprehension (Nuttall, 2005), enhanced
listening skills (Renandya & Jacobs, 2016),
mastering grammar (Celik, 2019) and boosting
speaking (Mart, 2012). In addition, a growing
Volume 12 - Issue 63
/ March 2023
137
http:// www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
number of scholars asserted that ER affects
motivation positively (Tanaka, 2017), changes
students’ overall attitudes towards learning
English in a positive way (Takase, 2009) and
reduces language learning anxiety sharply
(Kargar, 2013). Accordingly, there is a plethora
of study in this respect.
To name a few, Iwata (2022) conducted a study
on Japanese university students which revealed
that ER improved their reading fluency and
vocabulary knowledge considerably when they
read the books by choosing from different genres
available in the school library. Hussein Hakeem
Barzani (2020) conducted a study on university
students majoring in ELT at a private university
in Iraq which displayed that students noticed
positive effects of ER during their education
because ER helped them to fill the knowledge
gaps gradually and become proficient in English.
Additionally, Kargar conducted a notable study
in Iran context where she examined the effects of
ER on reading anxiety at a tertiary level which
revealed that ER reduced reading anxiety after
being exposed to graded readers. Afterwards,
Jang et al. (2015) explored the effects of ER on
motivation with Korean high school students
which unearthed that ER not only increased their
motivation but also developed their proficiency
in English. Similarly, Dickinson (2017) found
that Japanese university students changed their
overall attitude towards learning English after
being exposed to ER in a systematic way. They
reiterated that they were hopeful to master
English in the short run because they noticed that
language learning was not as challenging as
expected if materials were graded based on their
levels.
Some studies focused on the effects of online ER
on improving students linguistic competence.
To illustrate, Al-Jarf (2022) integrated mobile
fiction apps into the curriculum to support
students’ learning at a tertiary level in Saudi
Arabia which unearthed that they encouraged the
students to read more e-books based on fiction
stories and novels, so students’ attitudes towards
reading changed positively. Similarly, Keita
(2022) encouraged Japanese university students
to read books and take relevant quizzes on
XReader website which offers online books and
quizzes to promote reading rate globally. His
study uncovered that reading e-books and taking
quizzes increased students’ awareness to read
more carefully and get pleasure simultaneously.
Likewise, Zhou and Day (2021) conducted a
study at an American university which revealed
that XReading program improved their English
proficiency. The students asserted that using
portable devices and accessing electronic books
at any time were main reasons to join this study
more enthusiastically. In addition, Nkomo (2020)
conducted a pioneering study in South Africa on
primary school students which revealed that
online ER program not only improved them
academically but also personally. Students
reported that they improved their English and
became active speakers in conversations thanks
to reading various books electronically.
Apart from traditional and online ER, some
studies reflected the effects of hybrid ER
programs on improving students skills in
various domains. To name a few, Fatimah et al.,
(2022) conducted a study on Indonesian EFL
students at a tertiary level which revealed that
hybrid extensive reading activities raised the
standards in many dimensions. They attested that
reading books traditionally and electronically
increased students’ engagement, so they were
more motivated during the study which boosted
their overall performance dramatically.
Additionally, Kuru Gönen and Zeybek (2022)
carried out a pioneering study in Turkey on
integrating QR codes into ER books which
revealed that being directed to further
information to satisfy curiosity about certain
themes in the books increased EFL students’
motivation and marks tremendously in a British
culture course. Furthermore, Klassen and Allan
(2017) found that Japanese students increased
their success considerably when they read the
books from the library and took online quizzes on
MReader website which offers free quizzes for
graded readers globally.
Methodology
Research Design and Instruments
Research design to have been adopted in this
study was mixed methods on grounds that it
allows the researchers to use quantitative and
qualitative instruments based on the necessities.
Additionally, a mixed methods research design
reduces the pressure on the researcher to stick to
only one method which can limit the flexibility
to a great extent. Thus, the researcher had the
freedom to organize the study in a way to receive
numerical and verbalized data as equal as
possible and cross-check them (Morgan et al.,
2004; Dhakal, 2022). In this regard, a
questionnaire, an interview and a survey were
formed to receive quantitative data. The survey
and the questionnaire were analyzed by SPSS 23.
which required to use Cronbach Alpha reliability
test, Shapiro Wilkinson Normality Test, Mann
Whitney U Test, Frequencies. In addition, NVivo
138
www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
application was used to categorize the transcripts
in the interview and analyze accordingly.
Participants, Sampling and Setting
The setting of this study was TISHK
International University (TIU hereinafter) where
around 5000 students have received a top-notch
education in 29 departments in Erbil, Iraq as of
2022-2023 Academic Year. Convenience
sampling methods were employed to narrow the
population and analyze them thoroughly. Thus,
50 Foundation English course students out of 150
were chosen to initiate and finalize the study.
Foundation English course has been offered at
the university by TIU Language Preparatory
School as a technical non-elective course
spanning the whole year so that freshman
students, whose English levels are not sufficient
according to taken English proficiency exam, can
sharpen their English in 4 domains with
experienced and dynamic academicians. Their
lessons are enriched with CALL and MALL to
catch up with the demands of the 21st century and
keep the students engaged with real life
examples. Additionally, students are encouraged
to join some short talks and write some essays, so
they are granted privileges to improve their
English in a written and spoken format. The
underlying reason to choose TIU as the setting of
this study was that it has been offering all the
courses in English and encouraging the
academicians to take advantage of the current
trends in language learning and teaching process.
Validity and Reliability
The items in the questionnaire were cross-
checked by the committee who were experts in
testing and evaluation, so the researcher tested
the constructs in the questionnaire were relevant
and easy to comprehend. Thus, content validity
was ensured by updating the questions according
to the opinions of the experts. Later, Cronbach
Alpha was run to measure the reliability of the
items within 5 main categories which culminated
in .877, so internal reliability was also sufficient
enough to conduct the questionnaire in practice
with the participants.
Table 1.
Reliability statistics of piloting phase.
Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's Alpha
N of Items
.877
5
Procedure
The students joined this study for 11 weeks
which encompassed orientation workshops,
receiving consent forms, showing the
procedures, giving some tips to increase the
satisfaction rates. The first week was the
orientation period which was designed to
introduce the basics of e-book-based ER with
clear examples from around the world. In the
next step, students were provided with a wide
range of graded readers which were available in
the school library. Once students decide upon the
title of 5 books in cooperation, the researcher
provided audio-tracks and illustrated video
versions on YouTube. The conduct of the lesson
was to read and listen to the books individually
at first which converted to having reading,
listening, speaking and writing activities in the
second week. The rationale to have some
flexibility at first was that the students would get
pleasure and set their reading pace themselves
while they were reading. The researcher expected
that students would be more alert to join further
activities about the book if they read in advance.
In the second week, students read the chapters,
listened to the audio versions, summarized key
points, wrote a short summary and took a brief
quiz having only 5 questions for each book. The
essential difference of this study was that
students followed the activities with their mobile
devices to zoom in, go forward, rewind, use
dictionaries and be directed to other websites
related to the book summaries. This cycle was
repeated in each book. As can be seen, the
researcher prioritized 4 skills simultaneously to
support each other. When all the books were
covered and analyzed correspondingly, the
students took a survey and questionnaire to
collect the data, so students sincere opinions
could be uncovered.
Volume 12 - Issue 63
/ March 2023
139
http:// www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
Table 2.
Graded reader list chosen by the participants in cooperation.
Title
Author
Type
The number
of pages
Words
Level
Publisher
Eyes
Rob Sved
Narrative Non-fiction
32
672
1
Oxford
Earth
Richard
Northcott
Narrative Non-fiction
40
820
2
Oxford
Jobs
Kamini
Khanduri
Narrative Non-fiction
40
855
2
Oxford
Free Time
Around the
World
Julie Penn
Travelogue
48
1328
3
Oxford
Super Structures
Fiona Undrill
Narrative Non-fiction
48
1200
3
Oxford
Eyes illustrates the function of eye for animals
and people with distinctive examples.
Additionally, it depicts parts of an eye to teach
some daily- life words. Furthermore, it shows
positions, numbers of eyes. Subsequently, it
gives some tips to keep eyes safe and healthy.
Ducks, geckos, crabs, elephants, hawks,
monkeys, owls, sharks, frogs, chameleons, seals,
lemurs, dogs, cats, spiders, scallops, dragonflies,
camels, meercats and people are described
starkly in this book while describing
distinguishing qualities of eyes and their
importance. The lesson to be learned in this book
is that eyes can serve different purposes
according to the particular need of the
environment.
Earth helps the readers explore different places
on the Earth such as rivers, mountains, seas,
oceans, plains, deserts and forests. It also gives
information about Earth’s rotation and its
meaning for a sustained life. It also depicts some
mountains in China, cliffs in Australia, canyons
in Peru, caves in Slovenia, waterfalls in Canada
and deserts in the USA. Additionally, it shows
magnificent photos taken in the Arctic. In
addition, it tells that Monsoon Rains mean a
period of heavy rain in India; Amazon
Rainforests have diverse plants and animals in a
humid tropical climate. The lesson to be learned
in this book is that Earth is a vast area to explore
more and more.
Jobs introduces various jobs such as being a
doctor, a teacher, an office worker, a flight
attendant, a construction worker, a fire fighter, a
tour guide, a chef, a potter, a bus driver, a farmer,
a fisher, a miner, an engineer, a police officer, a
vet, a railway worker, a soccer player, a taxi
driver, a musician, a director, an actor, a producer
and a cameraperson. After describing their duties
consecutively, it gives further information about
their shifts which can be part-time or full-time.
The lesson to be learned in this book is that
chosen occupations may span the whole career,
so it is essential to choose a job through which
you will get pleasure and work with an increasing
enthusiasm each passing day.
Free Time Around the World illustrates different
free time activities based on the popularity for
given countries. For instance, it depicts that
football and futsal are so popular in Brazil where
players can play on the street with or without
trainers. Skiing, tobogganing, dog sledding are
popular winter sports in Canada. Additionally, an
artificial snow dome, built on a desert, in the
UAE allows the people to do different winter
sports. Subsequently, Bollywood dance is more
famous than any other ones in India and is
spreading to other countries as well. Moreover,
Tae kwon do is a national sport in South Korea
where it is so popular that some courses are
integrated into school curriculums about Tae
kwon do. Furthermore, manga, a type of comic
book, is the most popular genre in Japan. Also,
basketball is so popular in the USA and China
where there are many events to increase the
popularity of it. After that, singing, dancing and
playing instruments are popular pastimes in
Nigeria. Afterwards, beach sports are favorite
pastimes in Australia where a beach cricket
championship has been held annually. Finally,
scouting and cycling are popular pastime
activities in the UK and the Netherlands
respectively. The lesson to be learned in this
book is that there are different inclinations about
popular sports in each country mostly shaped by
the climate and promotions.
Super Structures promotes various schools,
bridges, castles, skyscrapers, tunnels with clear
examples. For example, it can be learned that
Seikan Tunnel in Japan is one of the longest
tunnels in the world. Likewise, Laerdal Tunnel in
Norway is one of the longest rod tunnels in the
world. In addition, the Lake Pontchartrain
Causeway is one of the longest beam bridges in
the USA. In addition, Burj Dubai and Petronas
Twin Towers are famous landmarks as
140
www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
skyscrapers in the UAE and Malaysia
respectively. Furthermore, the Itaupu Dam,
between Paraguay and Brazil, is one of the tallest
dams in the world. Subsequently, Beijing Capital
International Airport is one of the biggest
terminals in the world. The book also depicts
some structures with different shapes such as O2
in London, Biosphere in Arizona, Ice Hotel in
Sweden, the Poseidon Undersea Resort in Fuji,
Halley Research Station in the Antarctic, the
International Space Station in space.
The book ends with different structures built by
animals such as tunnels by wombats, dams by
beavers, mounds by termites. The lesson to be
learned in this book is that human beings and
animals are capable of building unique structures
according to their creativity and needs.
Considering the genres and levels, it can be
suggested that a variety of genres and levels were
integrated into e-book-based ER to increase the
engagement of the students.
Findings
Three subcategories, which were survey,
questionnaire, and survey were forged to
interpret the findings in detail. The findings of
each data collection tool can be explored below:
Survey
Items in the questionnaire included strengths and
weaknesses of e-book based ER activities and
students’ inclinations to join such studies in the
future voluntarily.
Table 3.
Thematic distribution of items on e-book based ER program
Items
Options
N
Percentage
What are some appealing sides
of e-book based ER?
Having fun in an interactive learning
environment
42
84 %
Expanding knowledge on numerous fields
46
92 %
Deriving pleasure
49
98 %
Developing a regular reading habit
39
78 %
Convenient to read via mobile technologies
41
82 %
Being more creative
44
88 %
Enhancing critical thinking skills
40
80 %
Mean
86 %
What are some weaknesses of e-
book based ER?
Distractibility
37
74 %
A variety of eye problems
34
68 %
Technophobia
4
8 %
Financial burdens
42
84 %
Battery related issues
46
92 %
Unable to take notes and transfer them
conveniently
47
94 %
Mean
70 %
Would you join a similar study
in the future?
Yes
41
82 %
No
9
18 %
Once Table 3 was analyzed on e-book-based ER,
it was observed that participants were asked to
choose some options which applied to them
regarding advantages, weaknesses and
preferences for a future study. To illustrate, they
emphasized getting pleasure, increasing
knowledge and being more creative as
advantages, however, they warned about
difficulty taking notes, distractibility, and
financial burdens as the weaknesses. When the
mean scores were compared, it was also revealed
that advantages of e-books (86 %) outweighed
the weaknesses (70 %). Another noteworthy
finding of the survey was about their preferences
which showed that an overwhelming majority of
the participants (92 %) would like to join such a
similar study in the future.
Questionnaire
Volume 12 - Issue 63
/ March 2023
141
http:// www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
Table 4.
Students’ Overall Satisfaction Rates within 5 primary categories
Construct
Item
Min
Max
Mean
SD
Variance
Macro-skills
E-book based ER program helped me
improve my reading skills.
2
5
4.58
0.81
0.657
E-book based ER program helped me
enhance my listening
performance.
3
5
4.86
0.45
0.204
E-book based ER program helped me
boost my speaking
performance.
3
5
4.66
0.56
0.311
E-book based ER program helped me
sharpen my writing skills
academically.
1
5
3.94
1.28
1.649
Micro-skills
E-book based ER program helped me
sharpen my grammatical
competence.
2
5
4.14
1.14
1.307
E-book based ER program helped me
boost my pronunciation.
4
5
4.8
0.4
0.163
E-book based ER program helped me
expand my vocabulary
knowledge.
4
5
4.6
0.5
0.245
Motivation
E-book based ER program helped me
increase my intrinsic motivation.
1
5
4.66
0.8
0.637
E-book based ER program helped me
spark my extrinsic motivation.
2
5
4.28
1.18
1.389
E-book based ER program helped me
restore my self-confidence in terms of
reading.
4
5
4.74
0.44
0.196
E-book based ER program helped me
restore my self-confidence in terms of
listening.
4
5
4.76
0.43
0.186
Overcoming
Language Learning
Anxiety
E-book-based ER program helped me
restore my self-confidence in terms of
speaking.
3
5
4.56
0.73
0.537
Overcoming
Language Learning
Anxiety
E-book-based ER program helped me
restore my self-confidence in terms of
writing .
2
5
4.12
0.77
0.598
Overall Attitudes
Towards learning
English
E-book based ER program changed my
overall attitudes towards learning English
positively.
4
5
4.96
0.2
0.039
Table 5.
The Analysis of 5 main categories.
Construct
Item
Min
Max
Mean
SD
Variance
Macro-skills
Developing 4 macro-
skills
3.5
5
4.51
0.452
0.204
Micro-skills
Improving 3 micro-skills
3.7
5
4.51
0.427
0.182
Motivation
Increasing intrinsic and extrinsic
motivation.
1
5
4.48
0.639
0.408
Overcoming Language
Learning Anxiety
Coping with language learning anxiety
in 4 domains.
3.8
5
4.54
0.377
0.142
Overall Attitudes
Towards learning
English
Being hopeful in the language learning
process.
4
5
4.96
0.198
0.039
142
www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
As shown in Table 4 and 5, e-book-based ER was
appreciated by the participants with varying
degrees in terms of macro-skills. For example,
their satisfaction level descended from listening
to writing. Although the satisfaction level was
significant in reading. listening and speaking, the
same satisfaction level was not observed in
writing. It can be argued that reading in large
volumes, listening to audio tracks and
summarizing the key points improved their skills
in 3 domains, however, writing necessitated
setting aside much time which could reduce the
number of books read in this study. It can be
stated that some modifications could be needed
to enhance students’ writing skills as well.
The questionnaire uncovered noteworthy points
in terms of sharpening micro-skills which
encompassed grammar, vocabulary and
pronunciation. The findings revealed that
participants noticed a considerable improvement
in vocabulary enhancement and pronunciation
thanks to following the program by reading and
listening to the audio-tracks simultaneously. In
other words, designing the reading and listening
activities harmoniously helped the participants to
have some gains in vocabulary and
pronunciation. However, grammatical
competence was not prioritized as it was the pre-
requisite of intensive reading activities. It can be
stated that ER could improve students’ macro
and micro skills with a well-established program.
Findings of the questionnaire on participants’
motivation deserve special attention as well. The
findings unearthed that their intrinsic motivation
was stimulated more than extrinsic motivation. In
other words, they participated in the activities in
a voluntary way rather than being motivated for
a reward or punishment. It can be stated that real-
life connections, having fun, learning
cooperatively could increase their enthusiasm
towards joining the reading activities more
actively.
Suffering from language learning anxiety is
another phenomenon which grips many students.
The findings in the questionnaire offered some
data to monitor closely. The majority of the
students reiterated that they stepped forward on
the way of fixing the obstacles in 4 macro-skills
except writing. This finding hints that more
connections needed to be built between ER and
writing.
The last construct in the questionnaire was
designed to measure whether participants were
driven to change their overall attitudes towards
learning English. Nearly all participants
unanimously chose strongly agree which can be
interpreted as a positive gain. It can be stated that
ER can support language learning process and
change students’ overall attitudes tremendously.
Once the items in the questionnaire were
analyzed categorically, it was observed that e-
book based ER produced more promising results
in terms of handling anxiety and changing overall
attitudes towards learning English. Additionally,
positive gains in other categories were also
appreciated with a 4.48 and higher mean scores.
It can be stated that the findings of the items were
consistent with the common categories.
Prior to conducting further analysis, a normality
test was run in order to figure out whether the
gathered data were distributed in a normal range
or not. This test was put into practice through
Shapiro Wilk formula of SPSS 23.0 for windows.
The criterion was whether p-value was higher or
less than 0.05. The result of normality test of the
writing test could be observed in the table 2.
Table 6.
Normality test of questionnaire items
Tests of Normality
a
Smirnov-Kolmogorov
Shapiro-Wilk
Statistic
df
Sig.
Statistic
df
Sig.
Macro-skills
.211
50
.000
.859
50
.000
Micro-skills
.213
50
.000
.862
50
.000
Motivation
.292
50
.000
.752
50
.000
Anxiety
.167
50
.001
.899
50
.000
Overall
Attitudes
.540
50
.000
.198
50
.000
a. Lilliefors Significance Correction
In this study, in inference statistics, if the data
was normal, parametric statistics was used which required t-test and if the data was not normal,
non-parametric statistics was applied which
Volume 12 - Issue 63
/ March 2023
143
http:// www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
required Mann Whitney U test. Once p-values of
Shapiro Wilk test were observed, they were
measured as .000 which was less than 0.05. The
p-values revealed that the distribution deviated
from the normal distribution in a significant way,
so it required to apply Mann Whitney U-test to
test whether there was a statistically significant
difference between the findings of the
questionnaire and independent variables such as
age and gender.
Table 7.
The Analysis of Mann Whitney U Tests in terms of age
Mann Whitney U Test
Age
Macro-skills
Micro-skills
Motivation
Anxiety
Overall
Attitudes
Mann-Whitney U
65.000
110.000
103.000
86.000
67.500
Wilcoxon W
1100.000
1145.000
118.000
101.000
82.500
Z
-1.572
-.084
-.332
-.876
-4.287
Asymp. Sig. (2-tailed)
.116
.933
.740
.381
.000
Exact Sig. [2*(1-tailed Sig.)]
b
.132
b
.950
b
.778
b
.412
b
.150
Upon analyzing the participants’ responses in
general, Mann Whitney U-test was run to
pinpoint whether there was a statistically
significant difference between participants in
terms of age and gender. Once p-values were
analyzed in terms of age, it was noticed that there
was no statistical difference between participants
except overall attitudes category. P- value,.000,
was less than 0.05, so a significant difference was
prevalent in overall attitude category, however
other p-values which were .116, .933, .740, .381
were higher than 0.05, so no significant
difference was observed between participants in
terms of age. It can be argued that participants
aged between 18 and 22 had a higher satisfaction
rate than 22 and 26 ones in terms of changing
overall attitudes toward language learning
process.
Table 8.
The Analysis of Mann Whitney U Tests in terms of gender
Mann Whitney U Test
Gender
Macro-skills
Micro-skills
Motivation
Anxiety
Overall
Attitudes
Mann-Whitney U
293.500
306.500
301.000
305.500
286.000
Wilcoxon W
699.500
712.500
554.000
558.500
692.000
Z
-.290
-.030
-.148
-.050
-1.267
Asymp. Sig. (2-tailed)
.772
.976
.882
.960
.205
Exact Sig. [2*(1-tailed Sig.)]
293.500
306.500
301.000
305.500
286.000
Moreover, participants were analyzed in terms of
gender which revealed that there was no
significant difference between male and female
ones. P-values were recorded .772, .976,
.882, .960, .205 consecutively, so no p-
value was less than 0.05. Considering these
figures, it can be argued that no statistical
difference was observed in terms of gender.
During the study, I got so much pleasure because
I joined all the activities willingly. The instructor
designed the lessons in an engaging way. We
read, listened to, spoke and wrote. Additionally,
we expressed our ideas about each book
independently. After that, the quizzes were so
useful to increase our comprehension and read
more carefully in the following days. Personally,
the most useful part of this study was about
improving pronunciation. I listened to the audio
tracks several times which helped me master my
pronunciation skills. I wish I had read book in
this version previously, so I could get so much
pleasure. (P 4)
I used to hate reading books during my high
school years because it was very tiring to read
and understand. However, we studied the books
chapter by chapter in this study which increased
my motivation. Additionally, we learned from
each other by telling the summaries. Once we
exchanged our ideas about the books, I saw that
there were many interesting points in the book.
Thus, I read the following books more eagerly to
notice more secrets and learn more novel
information. Splitting the activities into
manageable sessions in an interactive
environment was awesome for me. I am glad to
have joined such a unique study. (P 9)
144
www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
I am interested in travelling to different places,
so Earth, Free Time Around the World and Super
structures were real page-turners for me. I could
not stop reading them again and again because
there were many interesting details in them. Once
I read passionately, I joined all activities
willingly. As a result, my satisfaction rate was
quite high. Another point to be emphasized was
that we were granted the freedom to use our
mobile devices, so reading closely, using search
engine freely and expanding our knowledge
about the books on the web increased our
learning and motivation dramatically. (P13)
My favorite subject was geography in high
school, so the book named Earth was the best one
in this study. I learned a lot about the planets and
their functions. Additionally, I got much
information about mountains, deserts, rivers and
oceans. Once I continued reading and listening to
the sentences, I figured out many new words and
improved my pronunciation. In addition,
speaking and writing activities were designed by
considering our levels, so I derived so much
pleasure from beginning till the end. (P21)
My weakness in English is figuring out the topics
in listening. I practiced a lot to sharpen my
listening in this study. In addition, having e-book
and using mobile technologies increased my
motivation to read and listen to them as much as
I want. When I understood all topics easily in the
books, I could express my ideas confidently. As
a result, the period when I participated in
activities was a memorable one because I
increased my knowledge in terms of different
skills. (P34)
I learn better when I am exposed to learning
materials visually. The learning materials in this
study was enriched with visual materials, so I
was so enthusiastic to join activities voluntarily.
When I noticed that I could learn challenging
words without having difficulty, I looked
forward to having another memorable class. In
addition, our instructor corrected some our
pronunciation mistakes s/he noticed with the help
of an e-dictionary. Listening to the books and
reading aloud later helped us to fix many
mistakes related to pronunciation. Upon listening
to the books, we discussed common themes in
each book briefly which was also another mind-
blowing period. I was so satisfied with the top-
notch education provided in this study. (P37)
Our instructor urged us to form some groups and
complete some activities related to books. During
that time, we strengthened our relationship with
our friends. When we had a tight relationship
with them, we could ask further questions to
learn better. In addition, the students, whose
English levels were better than others, tutored the
other students who could not learn well. Once
students learned from each other, their success
rate rose accordingly. Transferring the sole
responsibility from the instructor to some clever
students yielded better results in this study. (P 39)
My weakness in English is writing which
demotivates me. In this study, we summarized
key points in a spoken and written format.
Although I improved my speaking dramatically,
I could not show the same success in writing. I
wished to have had more writing activities in this
study, but my instructor told me that reading and
listening were main areas to be developed in this
study.S/he also expressed that speaking and
writing activities were designed to support
reading and listening skills. I think I need to
study much more in Academic Writing course to
be better. (P41)
The most favorable part of this study was
boosting my intrinsic motivation. I got so much
pleasure as I progressed. I learned a wide variety
of words, fixed my chronic pronunciation
mistakes and restored my self-confidence.
Correspondingly, I could express my ideas easily
in speaking sessions. I realized that feeling
motivated for the sake of learning English and
getting pleasure individually was what I needed
most in language learning and teaching process.
(P45)
Upon completion of this study, I changed my
overall attitudes towards learning English. I had
some hesitations on language learning before
because of having some bitter experiences,
however, I took up new perspectives after this
study. I realized that language learning can be as
engaging as possible while reading books
because we not only study for main skills but also
have a chance to improve our micro-skills. There
is an idiom in English which is,’’ Kill two birds
with one stone.’’. It means that we can realize
multiple goals by doing only one action which
summarizes all my gains via this study. Now I
know how to expand my learning in English, so
I changed my overall attitudes towards learning
English. I am hopeful that I will master English
soon. (P 47)
Discussion
Recent innovations in digital technology have
prompted the researcher to integrate e-book
based ER into the curriculum and investigate its
effects thoroughly in this study. Considering the
Volume 12 - Issue 63
/ March 2023
145
http:// www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
findings of the study via a questionnaire, an
interview and a survey, several points were
highlighted which could be explored below:
Based on the findings in the questionnaire, the
participants stated that they improved their
macro-skills considerably. They reiterated that
they developed good habits towards reading,
listening and speaking, however, they demanded
more instructions in terms of writing. These
findings were consistent with Huang’s (2013)
study which revealed that e-book paves the way
for e- discussion, so students can expand their
learning in all skills subconsciously.
Subsequently, the participants attested that they
increased their knowledge in terms of
pronunciation and vocabulary. In contrast, they
also postulated that grammatical competence was
not triggered as much as expected. It was in line
with Isaqjon’s (2022) finding which unearthed
that intensive reading was implemented to
develop students’ grammatical competence,
however, extensive reading did not prioritize
teaching grammar units. Likewise, Kirchhoff and
Mision (2022) assert that audio assisted ER is a
rational idea to teach some words and develop
pronunciation. Another notable finding of the
questionnaire was on motivation. The
participants stated that they improved their
intrinsic motivation more than extrinsic one
because they read for the sake of getting pleasure
and meaning throughout the process. Celik
(2018) elucidates that reading e-books drive the
learners to read regularly, so they read more
willingly in a more motivated way. Apart from
macro-skills, micro-skills, motivation,
participants’ opinions were explored in terms of
overcoming language learning anxiety which
affects many learners adversely. The participants
articulate that the study helped them to overcome
their language anxiety in four domains. This
finding was in line with Turel and Sanal’ s (2018)
study which reported that e-book based ER can
train the readers on how to overcome language
learning barriers and read more confidently. The
last thing to think about in the questionnaire was
that almost all of the people who filled it out said
that their overall feelings about learning English
had changed. Pattuelli and Rabina (2010) and
Yildiz (2020) say that e-book activities
encourage learners to change their overall
attitudes about learning English because learners
can see the positive effects of e-books right away
and this leads to academic success.
Findings of the interview emphasized
noteworthy dimensions of e-book reading as
well. To name a few, many students reported that
they were more engaged to enhance their
learning. In addition, the study helped them to
overcome their weaknesses such as expressing
their ideas in a confident way, comprehending
conversations in the audio tracks and handling
chronic pronunciation mistakes. Subsequently,
they asserted that they removed some barriers in
their minds, so their overall attitudes towards
learning the language by technologically
enriched proven techniques yielded fruitful
results. After that, they stated that reading e-
books expanded their learning in other skills
thanks to having an integrated approach to teach
language through e-books.
The findings of the survey unearthed essential
points to be considered as well. The participants
appreciated e-book-based ER for having fun,
expanding knowledge, deriving pleasure,
developing a regular reading habit, being more
creative and improving critical thinking skills.
Waller (2013) elucidates that e-books are
feasible because learners can have fun, read in
large numbers and derive pleasure, read more
frequently, stimulate their creativity and evaluate
the events from a critical perspective. The
participants also stated that using mobile
technologies in class enhanced their
performance. Kara (2020) asserts that using
mobile technologies in classroom activities can
take the education into another level, so multiple
benefits can be gained simultaneously if planned
and monitored professionally. On the other hand,
the participants alleged that some drawbacks
such as distractibility, being unaffordable,
leading to poor vision, suffering from
technophobia, unable save notes conveniently
and charging issues may reduce the positive
effects of e-book-based ER. Alsadoon (2020)
convenes that some barriers related to
concentration, affordability and health can hinder
students’ learning rates in e-book based reading
activities. The last item in the survey was
whether they had positive views to join such a
study again in the future which culminated in a
hopeful way. All students except 9 stated that
they would join an e-book-based ER voluntarily
in the future. Noor et al., (2012) proposed that e-
book-based reading satisfaction rate made it a
reasonable technique to implement in future
studies.
Conclusion and Recommendations
This study sought the effects of e-book-based ER
program on students’ performance, motivation
and devising ways to overcome language
learning anxiety. Analyzed and cross-checked
data revealed that students improved their
primary skills considerably except writing. In
146
www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
addition, it was indicated that students sharpened
their pronunciation and expanded their
vocabulary power. However, the same success
could not be observed in improving grammatical
competence. In terms of motivation, intrinsic
motivation was triggered more than extrinsic
motivation. Subsequently, students reiterated
that e-book-based ER encouraged them to
overcome language learning anxiety in 4
domains. The final point to be considered was
that they changed their overall attitudes
drastically at the end of the study.
Some recommendations can be made for future
studies. This study welcomed students’ opinions
on e-book-based ER which could be enriched
with the exam results. Additionally, this study
employed an ER based instruction which could
be compared with an intensive reading group.
Subsequently, the number of male students were
less that female ones which could be equalized to
get a more satisfying data from each gender.
Moreover, the data was collected from a
university which can be expanded with other
educational institutions in the region.
Bibliographic References
Abdulrahman, S. A., & Kara, S. (2023). The Effects
of Movie-Enriched Extensive Reading on
TOEFL IBT Vocabulary Expansion and
TOEFL IBT Speaking Section Score. Journal of
Qualitative Research in Education, 33.
Al-Jarf, R. (2022). Mobile Fiction Apps for
Enhancing EFL Students' Reading and
Appreciation Skills. International Journal of
Linguistics Studies, 2(2), 15-23.
Alsadoon, H. (2020). Obstacles to using E-books in
higher education. International Journal of
Education and Literacy Studies, 8(2), 44-53.
Celik, B. (2018). Effects of extensive reading on
learners: How it develops certain points in
vocabulary and sentence structure. International
Journal of English Linguistics, 8(2), 73-84.
Celik, B. (2019). The role of extensive reading in
fostering the development of grammar and
vocabulary knowledge. International Journal of
Social Sciences & Educational Studies, 6(1),
215-223.
Daskan, A., & Yildiz, Y. (2020). A simultaneous
dual focus on form and meaning to enhance
language learning. International Journal of
Social Sciences & Educational Studies, 7(4),
59-63.
Day, R. R. (2018). Extensive reading. In J. I.
Liontas, T. International Association & M. Delli
Carpini, (Eds.), The TESOL encyclopedia of
English language teaching (pp.1-7).
https://doi.org/10.1002/
9781118784235.eelt0472
Dewey, J. (1938). Experience and education. New
York: Macmillan
Dhakal, K. (2022). NVivo. Journal of the Medical
Library Association, 110(2), 270-272.
Dickinson, P. (2017). Effects of extensive reading
on EFL learner reading attitudes. In Selected
papers of the 21st conference of Pan-Pacific
association of applied linguistics (pp. 28-35).
http://paaljapan.org/conference2016/pdfs/04.pd
f
Fatimah, A. S., Marlina, N., & Dewi, N. S. N.
(2022). Scrutinizing Activities in Online
Extensive Reading Classroom: Highlighting
Students Voice. AL-ISHLAH: Journal of
Education, 14(3), 2993-3006.
Fraser, M., & Abbott, M. (2016). Using electronic
readers: Action research in an intermediate
adult ESL class. The Canadian Journal of
Action Research, 17(2), 3-18.
Horst, M. (2005). Learning L2 vocabulary through
extensive reading: A measurement study.
Canadian Modern Language Review, 61(1),
355-382. doi:10.3138/cmlr. 61.3.355
Huang, H. C. (2013). E-reading and e-discussion:
EFL learners' perceptions of an e-book reading
program. Computer Assisted Language
Learning, 26(3), 258-281.
Hussein Hakeem Barzani, S. (2020). Kurdish efl
students’ attitudes and preferences toward
extensive reading. PalArch's Journal of
Archaeology of Egypt/Egyptology, 17(7),
8192-8207.
Isaqjon, T. (2022). Strategies and techniques for
improving EFL learnersreading skills. Involta
Scientific Journal, 1(11), 94-99.
Iwata, A. (2022). The Effectiveness of Extensive
Reading (ER) on the Development of EFL
Learners’ Sight Vocabulary Size and Reading
Fluency. The Reading Matrix: An International
Online Journal, 22(2), 74-91.
Jang, H., Kang, M., & Kim, Y. (2015). The effect
of English extensive reading activities on
students reading proficiency and reading
motivation. Advanced Science and Technology
Letters, 92(1), 92-95.
Kara, S. (2020). Letting Smartphones at Class
Times: Does It Matter in Learning
Process? International Journal of Social
Sciences & Educational Studies, 7(1), 78-87.
Kara, S., & Yildiz, Y. (2022). From a commodity to
addiction: Are mobile phones valuable
commodities or sources of addiction for
freshman students? Amazonia
Investiga, 11(56), 196-209.
https://doi.org/10.34069/AI/2022.56.08.20
Kargar, A. A. (2013). Investigating the effect of
scaffolded extensive reading as an anxiety
reducing strategy in an Iranian EFL
context. International Journal of Foreign
Language Teaching and Research, 1(1),
35-44.
Volume 12 - Issue 63
/ March 2023
147
http:// www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
Keita, Y. (2022). An Exploratory Study of an
Extensive Reading Program with Xreading in a
Japanese University. ICU Language Research
Bulletin, 37(1), 24-34.
https://doi.org/10.34577/00005194
Kirchhoff, C., & Mision, M. (2022). Audio-assisted
Extensive Reading: Learners’ Experience and
Attitudes. The Reading Matrix: An
International Online Journal, 22(2), 1-12.
Klassen, J., & Allen, D. M. (2017). Assessing the
risk of saltwater intrusion in coastal
aquifers. Journal of Hydrology, 551,
730-745.
Krashen, S. (1992). The input hypothesis: An
update. Linguistics and language pedagogy:
The state of the art, 409-431.
Krashen, S. D., & Terrell, T. (1983). Natural
approach (pp. 20-20). New York: Pergamon.
Kumar, K. V., & Palukuri, V. (2022). Does
Instructions Enhance Reading Comprehension
Abilities in the ESL Classroom? Journal of
Positive School Psychology, 6(2), 5755-5758.
Kuru Gönen, S. İ., & Zeybek, G. (2022). Using QR
code enhanced authentic texts in EFL extensive
reading: a qualitative study on student
perceptions. Education and Information
Technologies, 27(2), 2039-2057.
Mart, C. T. (2012). Developing speaking skills
through reading. International Journal of
English Linguistics, 2(6), 91-96.
Morgan, G. A., Leech, N. L., Gloeckner, G. W., &
Barrett, K. C. (2004). SPSS for introductory
statistics: Use and interpretation. Psychology
Press.
Nation, I. S. P. (2009). Teaching ESL/EFL reading
and writing. New York, NY: Routledge.
Nkomo, S. A. (2020). Implementing a bilingual
extensive reading programme in the Foundation
Phase: Theory and practice. Per Lingua: A
Journal of Language Learning = Per Lingua:
Volume for Language Learning, 36(2),
126-137.
Noor, A. M., Ali, R. M. M., Bakar, Z. A., &
Amin, A. R. M. (2012). Teachers-Perceptions
on the Use of E-Books as Textbooks in the
Classroom. International Journal of Educational
and Pedagogical Sciences, 6(10), 2638-2644.
Nuttall, C. (2005). Teaching reading skills in a
foreign language. Oxford, England: Macmillan
Education.
Pattuelli, M. C., & Rabina, D. (2010, May). Forms,
effects, function: LIS students' attitudes towards
portable e‐book readers. In Aslib
Proceedings (Vol. 62, No. 3, pp. 228-244).
Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
Renandya, W. A., & Jacobs, G. M.
(2016). Extensive reading and listening in the
L2 classroom (pp. 97-110). Springer
International Publishing.
Robb, T., & Kano, M. (2013). Effective ex-tensive
reading outside the classroom: A large-scale
experiment. Reading in a Foreign Language,
25(2), 234-247.
Takase, A. (2009). The effects of different types of
extensive reading materials on reading amount,
attitude and motivation. Extensive reading in
English language teaching, 7(1), 451-465.
Tanaka, M. (2017). Factors affecting motivation for
short in-class extensive reading. Journal of Asia
TEFL, 14(1), 98-113.
Turel, Y. K., & Sanal, S. O. (2018). The effects of
an ARCS based e-book on student's
achievement, motivation and
anxiety. Computers & Education, 127,
130-140.
Ulker, U., Ulker, V., Celik, B., Yildiz, Y., &
Bilgin, R. (2021). E-Book Reading Genre
Preferences of Teachers Teaching in Foreign
Languages in Private Schools (Case
Study/Iraq). International Journal of Social
Sciences & Educational Studies, 8(4), 158-170.
Vygotsky, L. (2011). Interaction between learning
and development. Reading on the Development
of Children, 7(1), 34-40. Retrieved from:
https://ia.eferrit.com/ea/a6589cd862231ed3.pd
f
Waller, D. (2013). Current Advantages and
Disadvantages of Using E-Textbooks in Texas
Higher Education. FOCUS on Colleges,
Universities & Schools, 7(1), 1-6.
Yildiz, Y. (2019). EFL learners’ needs in
preparatory schools and supplementary
techniques to improve their language
proficiency. International Journal of Academic
Research in Business and Social Sciences, 9(1),
586-596.
Yildiz, Y. (2020). Reading habit and its role on
students’ academic success at language
preparatory school: A research on Tishk
International University preparatory school
students. Amazonia Investiga, 9(27),
189-194.
https://doi.org/10.34069/AI/2020.27.03.20
Yildiz, Y., & Yucedal, H. M. (2020). Learner
autonomy: A central theme in language
learning. International Journal of Social
Sciences & Educational Studies, 7(3),
208-212.
Zhou, J., & Day, R. R. (2021). Online extensive
reading in EAP courses. Reading in a Foreign
Language, 33(1), 103-125.
http://hdl.handle.net/10125/67395