Volume 11 - Issue 60
/ December 2022
235
http:// www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
DOI: https://doi.org/10.34069/AI/2022.60.12.25
How to Cite:
Akansu, V., & Duman, Ü. (2022). Applying Portugal exemplar to Varosha region of Cyprus for the identification of new
refunctioning criteria for city spaces. Amazonia Investiga, 11(60), 235-248. https://doi.org/10.34069/AI/2022.60.12.25
Applying Portugal exemplar to Varosha region of Cyprus for the
identification of new refunctioning criteria for city spaces
KENTSEL MEKANLARA GETİRİLECEK YENİ DÜZENLEME KRİTERLERİNİN
BELİRLENMESİNDE PORTEKİZ ÖRNEĞİNİN KIBRIS KAPALI MARAŞ
BÖLGESİNE UYARLANMASI
Received: November 11, 2022 Accepted: December 30, 2022
Written by:
Vedia Akansu114
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1915-2744
Ümran Duman115
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2385-5605
Abstract
There is a need for research in the field of re-
functionalization of cities and its overall
contribution to the economic, social and cultural
diversity of a city as well as the international
application of projects. The area of Expo’ 98 city
project in Portugal was chosen as an exemplar
due to its design criteria, materials and functional
arrangements. Parallel with the project Expo 98,
an alternative project would be presented in the
re-functioning process of Varosha in Cyprus
which is an ongoing hot debate. This alternative
will also contribute to the determination of the
new regulation criteria in city spaces. Therefore,
Varosha was re-organised with these criteria. In
this study, observation and comparison were
made through the theoretical information
gathered from Expo’98 fair held in Portugal. As
a result, new regulation criteria were determined
in line with the proposed model. Thus, a new
urban arrangement was offered for the city of
Varosha.
Keywords: urban-suburban relationship, re-
functioning, brownfield, Expo’98, Lisbon,
Varosha.
Introduction
There are many factors which affect the urban
development process. The strategic location of
the city, the coexistence of residents who comes
from different cultures and different economic
backgrounds, changing and developing social
114
M. Arch, Department of Architecture, Faculty of Architecture, Near East University, Turkey.
115
M. Arch, Department of Architecture, Faculty of Architecture, Near East University, Turkey.
relationships, and political changes are among
these factors. Thus, it is possible to observe
preserved historical texture in some regions of
the city and changes and development in others,
based on the conditions of the period. Some other
236
www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
regions, however, await for renewal in unusable
and idle condition. These regions (brownfields),
negatively affect the environment and cause
social disadvantages in the region (Randolph &
Freestone, 2008). Therefore, it is important to
restore the functionality of such areas. One of the
main concerns of the design is the parallel
development of the city, city centre and suburban
during the improvement of these areas. Based on
this point of view and considering the current
development and changes, the idle state of
Varosha is a problematic situation which should
be dealt with immediately. Varosha once was a
tourist destination, however, today it is full of
abandoned hotels. Varosha evidences the
contradicting political desires and economic
expectations and it is involved in negotiations for
political reconciliation in Cyprus (Pyla &
Phokaides, 2020). Varosha which was
internationally recognised before 1974, today
creates social and cultural disadvantages with its
current idle (brownfield) state. Although a
certain area was opened for visitation of the civil
population, majority parts of Varosha are still
closed. Necessary landscape and infrastructure
developments have been completed.
Furthermore, certain user groups have usage
permits for some of the buildings. Several
furnished hotels, entertainment centres,
commercial buildings, business suites, libraries
and residential structures that are not currently
being used are abandoned and problematic
spaces. Therefore, it is crucial to redevelop and
offer these buildings for public use.
The literature review on abandoned spaces which
was conducted within this context, suggests
abandoned real estates owned by individuals or
commercial spaces. Dominantly,
recommendations for these types of spaces have
proposed structures with mixed usage
opportunities for locals. The examined
exemplars have included Boca Raton, abandoned
Florida Mizner Park Shopping Mall and
Chatanooga, Tenessee Eastgate Shopping Mall
in the USA. (Feronti, 2003; Dover & Partners
Town Planning, 1998). These examples are
unused structures on abandoned plots in
functional regions. Contrarily, Varosha is
abandoned and unused region. Similar
restoration examples include Berlin-Adlershof,
Bilbao-Abandoibarra, Dublin-Docklands
Development Project (along with International
Financial Services Centre), Melbourne-
Docklands Project, Viana-Donau City and
Lisbon-Expo’98 projects (Swyngedouw et al.,
2002). Examination of these projects reveals that
usually old industrial and/or harbour areas (with
a sea or river shore) are restored. The reason why
Lisbon-Expo’98 was chosen as an exemplar was
not only its climate, land structure, user needs,
assigned importance of supporting potential
tourism activities and other similarities but also
its applicability to Varosha. Furthermore, as a
successful project, Lisbon-Expo’98 has been
adopted by several other country examples
before. Thus, Varosha resonates with Expo’98
project which has an international success as a
restoration of abandoned brownfield. Therefore,
within the context of this study, Varosha has been
considered parallel as the abandoned industrial
and harbour area that lays along the Tagus River
which was restored and acquired a new identity
with Lisbon-Expo’98. Although abandoned,
there have been recent steps towards to reopen
the region of Varosha. Therefore, this study aims
to review and reintegrate Varosha with the city in
the light of Expo’98 project.
The study methodology consists of an
examination of Expo’98 strategies (level of
planning, design, finance, development and
management) and regional planning which was
put forward with the help of identified axes and
they will be applied to Varosha. In the renovation
process of Varosha, the establishment of a
physical relationship with the Mediterranean and
coastal settlement and integration with the
existing urban texture will be taken into
consideration. In addition to its contribution to
the projects that will be carried out in the region,
the resulting study is expected to be taken as an
example for the projects aimed at revitalising the
brownfields.
The parts of this article are designed as follows.
Next section summarises the literature review.
Section 3 explains the materials and
methodology; adaptation of Expo’98 project to
Varosha region. Section 4 includes the evaluation
of criteria which were taken into account during
determining project strategies for Varosha. It also
puts forwards the assessment of the zoning work
and axes which were determined at the planning
stage. The last section provides a summative
evaluation of the findings of this article based on
a review of the existing literature and fieldwork.
Literature review
Varosha, one of the settlements of Famagusta
once was a trade and tourism centre. However,
this situation had only been sustained for 15
years. From time to time, political and economic
factors can create changes in cities and Varosha
region is one of the examples that experienced
change. The word “Varosha” was used for the
first time to identify this region in the archive
Akansu, V., & Duman, Ü. / Volume 11 - Issue 60: 235-248 / December, 2022
Volume 11 - Issue 60
/ December 2022
237
http:// www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
documents of dated 28.1.1573. The region,
which is still called “Varosha” by Greek Cypriots
is known as Maraş (Mustafa Mutlu İbili, 2011).
According to different sources, the name Maraş
(Merash) was used by Richard Pococke for the
first time in 1738 (Cobham, 1969). The region
has an area of 450 hectares (Google Earth, 2019).
It is also known that the land on which Varosha
was settled once belonged to Ottoman foundation
and it was transferred to Famagusta Greek
Municipality in 1898 during the British Period
(Mustafa Mutlu İbili, 2011). (Figure 1.)
Figure 1. Varosha- Open Varosha Foundation Land (Kapalı Maraş Çocukları, 2019).
The most popular period of Varosha was the first
couple of years of the Republic of Cyprus.
Varosha continued to develop, although a
political conflict was experienced between
Cypriot Turks and Cypriot Greeks from 1960 to
1974. However, with the Peace Operation held
in 1974, residents of Varosha were evacuated and
the region was closed down for civilian use.
Initially, it was believed that Varosha was held as
leverage during the peace negotiations between
Cypriot Greeks and Cypriot Turks. However,
later on, it was described as Ghost Town by the
international media (Boğaç, 2020). Varosha is
located in the buffer zone known as the Green
Line which divides the island of Cyprus into two
sectors, and this zone is under the jurisdiction of
the United Nations since 1974. The Green Line
(buffer zone), determines the two separate states
that exist in Cyprus, Greek Cypriot
Administration of Southern Cyprus, and the
Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (Bueno-
Lacy & van Houtum, 2018). Within this context,
it is crucial to examine the developments
occurred for Varosha before and after 1974.
238
www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
Condition of Varosha before 1974
During the British Colonial Period, while
Turkish Cypriots were living within the
Famagusta City Walls, Greek Cypriots were
living in the part of Varosha which is closer to
the shore and eventually became West of
Varosha today as a result of the expansion of the
settlements at the shore towards the East (İbili,
2011). This part of Varosha was never closed
down (Figure 2. and Figure 3.).
Figure 2. Varosha and the West of Varosha regional borders and their relationship with Famagusta City
Centre (Rafiemanzelat, 2014)
Figure 3. Settlement Regions of Turkish Cypriots and Greek Cypriots in Famagusta and Varosha before
1974 (Christodoulou, 2016)
As a settlement town, Varosha experienced a
wave of interest towards the end of 1960s and the beginning of 1970s from a series of investors
who have built hotels (Sterling, 2014). Thus, it
Volume 11 - Issue 60
/ December 2022
239
http:// www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
has become one of the most important towns in
the Mediterranean. Before 1974, as a town
located on the East shore of the island of Cyprus
with over 39,000 population, Varosha’s
importance was attributed to its famous
cosmopolitan region which was developing as a
tourism and trade centre (Michael, 2011). It is
known that the civil war in Lebanon is one of the
reasons for the growing interest in Varosha, like
Beirut, once, one of the famous tourism and
entertainment destinations of the Mediterranean
lost its attraction due to the civil war. The other
factors for the attraction of Varosha were the
location of Cyprus which enables easy access to
Europe, its natural beaches, its climate in
particular and its attraction for the western
Europeans with high income (Akengin & Kaykı,
2013). Thus, the region became a dynamically
developed and growing settlement.
Varosha has consisted of three areas. Tourism
area was located on the coastal part of the region
whereas residential area and social-
administrative centre were located in the west of
Varosha. According to the pre-1974 archive of
Famagusta Municipality, the distribution of the
buildings in Varosha were as such; 45 hotels with
10,000-bed capacity, 60 apartment type hotels,
3,000 commercial units, 99 entertainment
centres, 143 management offices, 4649 private
houses, 21 banks, 24 theatres, and cinemas, 1
library and 380 unfinished constructions (Boğaç,
2002).
Figure 4. A picture of Varosha (pre-1974) (Detay, 2019)
Also, it is known that Greek lands were leased to
foreign investors by granting long-term
investment permits for 50-100 years periods to
international companies (Italian, German,
British) based on build-operate-transfer contract
model (Mustafa Mutlu İbili, 2011).
Based on all these researches, it is possible to
conclude that Varosha was an active area until
1974.
Varosha After 1974
Varosha, which experienced its heyday between
1960 and 1974, lost its attraction after 1974. As
a result of 1974 occurrences, 4,469 families had
to flee from Varosha which still carries the traces
of war and since then, it became a completely
abandoned town. Today, there are 8,852
buildings in Varosha some of which are 10-15
floored apartment flats, and a majority of the
other buildings are most luxury hotels and
casinos. All the commercial and tourism
activities were halted as a result of the
unfortunate occurrences (Akengin & Kaykı,
2013).
Located on the coastal line of Famagusta city, as
a tourism area, Varosha surrounded with military
fences after 1974 operation. The terms “frozen
town”, “urban destruction” and “ghost city” also
represent Varosha. The residential area and
administrative centre of Varosha (west of
Varosha) on the other hand, remained in use
where Turkish families from Turkey and South
Cyprus were placed for the maintenance of the
abandoned agricultural lands and orange groves
and the sustainability of the fruit and vegetable
production (Önal et al., 1999). Today, there is no
sign of life in Varosha but abandoned buildings
(Bjorkdahl & Kappler, 2017).
240
www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
Figure 4. A street view of Varohsa after 1974 (Akansu, 2020)
Figure 4 represents the scenery that families
residing on the unrestricted part of Varosha are
exposed daily.
Lisbon Expo’98
World’s Fair Expo was held in 1851 for the first
time in England. The term “Expo” which comes
from the word ‘Exposition’, names the world’s
fairs. In 1998, in its city of Lisbon, Portugal
hosted this fair which regularly operates in
different cities of the world. Expo’ 98 fair
provided an opportunity to create a truly touristic
area on a brownfield (Benhamou, 2019).
Additionally, this city has been an important
commercial place since the 15th century in
Europe. Expo’98 fair aimed to revitalise the
abandoned Lisbon port and industrial zone. The
project was held as part of the 500th anniversary
of Vasco de Gama’s journey to India with The
Oceans, A Heritage for the Future theme
(Monclús, 2009).
Analysis of Expo’98 Planning Stages
Expo’98 plan is the first prudential urban and
architectural plan which is highly accepted
among world fairs. This is the first exposition
where with a clear strategy, urban planning,
urban design, and architecture were assembled
with a model on a strong financial budget.
Harmonious planning has been made to support
the long term use of the city. The plan allows the
use of lands and iconic buildings. Vassalo Rasa,
the project leader of this plan stated that in public
space design, the aspects such as urban
appearance, its physical relationship with the
river and its surroundings and its coherence with
the existing urban texture were taken into
consideration (Aelbrecht, 2014).
340 idle hectare used in the planning, were
divided into 6 main areas each of which were
designed by different designers. The areas were
designated as 1. The central zone, 2. Enclosure
zone, 3. South zone- residential area and port, 4.
North zone- Residential zone, 5. Sacavém zone
and 6. Large city park zone located in the north
(Akansu, 2016) (figure 5).
Figure 5. Expo’98 the areas of the designed project (Akansu, 2016).
Volume 11 - Issue 60
/ December 2022
241
http:// www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
Additionally, four main axes which were
designated during the planning stage are
determined in figure 3 as the public axis. Public
axis is a vertical axis along the river where public
facilities such as the station, shopping centre, and
the main square (Rossio dos Olivais) are found.
The main axis is the only axis which enables
pedestrians and vehicles access to the city centre
and its neighbourhood. Leisure axis, on the other
hand, is a pedestrian axis which lies along the
river. Secondary axis is a traffic axis which
functions as a backbone that connects the north
and south residential areas and central public
space (Aelbrecht, 2014) (Figure 6).
Figure 6. 4 regulatory axis, determined in Expo’98 (Aelbrecht, 2014)
Two important aims were taken into consideration during the planning stage; self-finance of the designated
area, and the harmonious reconstruction of the area with its environment (Monclús, 2009). It was necessary
to determine the project strategies, during the development stage of these aims. In this regard, Expo’98
strategies emerged as planning, design, development-management and financial stages (Table 1).
Table 1.
Expo’98 project strategies
Expo’98 Project Strategies
(1) Planning Stage
(2) Design Stage
(3)Development, Management and
Financial Stage
Planning activities were initiated
before and after expo collectively. Aim: To create a hub and to organise
Expo Fair. Pillars: -To enable diversified usage
(residential, service areas and
commercial units) -To arrange economic resources -To develop the strategic infrastructure
Design Architectural Design:
of temporary and permanent
structures with the intention of
reuse.
Urban Design: -To design double functional,
communal areas with the idea
of permanency and
functionality
Model Development/Management:
-To establish a private company,
‘Parque Expo’ which has the
responsibilities to design a world fair,
build and disassemble, at the same
time can purchase of regional land,
develop and sell and has access to
public funding.
r, the After Expo fai Financial Model:
sales of the completed project to
private investors and developers (land
and pavilion).
(Aelbrecht, 2014, adopted by the authors).
In regards to data in table 1, different access
strategies were taken into consideration during
the planning stage as a first aim. Thus, national
and international roads were planned. The second
aim, on the other hand, was to enable diversified
usage (Aelbrecht, 2014). In this regard, north and
south areas of the expo were mainly separated as
residential areas and, public facilities in central
were evenly partitioned for commercial, leisure
and cultural activities. To ensure diversified
usage, a single station was planned for train, bus
and metro services. Additionally, Expo’98
242
www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
accommodates many different facilities such as
Lisbon expedition centre, aquarium, and multi-
functional pavilion, a variety of public spaces,
parks, hospital, and university. Industrial and
port areas which were previously abandoned,
were restored for the public use within the
context of reconstruction (Figure 7).
Figure 7. Expo’98, before and after states (Instituto Camões-Parque Expo98, 2000. Access date: 06.08.19)
After the implementation of Expo’98, a user
satisfaction survey was conducted and it revealed
that users were satisfied with the outcome.
Furthermore, pavilion and most of the public
spaces have received both national and
international awards. Parque Expo has been
assigned an urban transformation programme as
a result of this interest in public space. Since
then, Parque Expo became a consulting firm
specialising in urban spaces around the globe
with a portfolio including Chicomba in Angola,
Receife in Brazil, Praia in Cape Verde, and Cairo
in Egypt (Aelbrecht, 2014). This is evidence that
Expo’98 planning is a very crucial reference for
other projects.
Material and method
This study is conducted based on observations of
the project presented at Lisbon Fair (Expo’98)
and a comparative approach between that project
and Varosha. The similarities between Varosha
and Expo’98 area contributed to the applicability
of the project. The priority was given to the
implementation of the project strategies, zoning
and axes which were stated at the planning stage
to Varosha to enable its functioning.
Accordingly, Expo’98 project strategies,
planning stages, design stages and development/
management/ financial stages were taken into
account in applying these to Varosha. At the
planning stage, enabling diversified usage, the
arrangement of economic resources, and
development of strategic infrastructure were
prioritised. At the design stage, both architectural
and urban design were considered. Development,
management and financial sages would all
support the financial model through model
development and management. Furthermore, the
axes which are determined at the land description
and design helps to decide the regions and the
creation of the transportation network.
Case Town: Varosha
Cyprus is an Island located on the East of the
Mediterranean with the Mediterranean climate
(Delipetrou et al., 2008). Due to the
characteristics of its climate, it is one of the
important centres of tourism and related
commercial activities. In the North of the Island,
there are five major cities which are Nicosia,
Kyrenia, Famagusta, Trikomo and Morphou.
Among these cities, Famagusta is an important
port city. Although dominantly port cities are
characterised by commercial trade, they also
have a tourism function (Kaypak, 2012).
According to Famagusta Chamber of Trade and
Industry, referring to the period right before
1974, although Famagusta population
constituted 7% of the Island’s population, the
city was providing 10% of the Island’s
employment. 50% of the hotel accommodation
capacity of Island was in Famagusta.
Furthermore, 50% of the Island’s arrivals
through sea-transportation were coming from
Famagusta port and 83% of the postal and cargo
services were handled at Famagusta Port
(Keshisian, 1985).
Determining the Implementation Method of
Expo’98 Planning Stages to Varosha
The reason why the Expo’98 project was chosen
as the exemplar in determining the method for
this study is that there are many similarities and
differences between the Expo’98 region and
Varosha. These similarities and differences are
presented in Table 2.
Volume 11 - Issue 60
/ December 2022
243
http:// www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
Table 2.
Comparison of Expo’98 and Varosha
COMPARISON OF EXPO’98 AND VAROSHA
Expo’98
Varosha
SIMILARITIES
The land that Expo’98 project has been
implemented, used to be a Brownfield.
After 1974, Varosha became a brownfield.
It a land that lies along Tagus Riverbank.
It is a land that lies along the Mediterranean shore.
Due to its location, it has a connection to the
historical texture of Lisbon city.
Due to its location, it has a connection to the
historical texture of Famagusta city.
DIFFERENCES
It was an abandoned industrial and portal region.
It is an abandoned commercial and tourism region.
There was abandoned industrial and portal
waste.
There are abandoned lands, existing buildings and
unfinished constructions.
It is 350 hectares of unused land.
It is a ~ 450 hectares of unused land.
It is at a location where an international railway
passes through.
It is ~2 km away from Famagusta Trading Port.
There was no evidence of flora and fauna.
The region became a living area of flora and fauna
densely.
Based on the comparison, it was decided that
Expo’98 can be applied to Varosha. Varosha was
evaluated based on Expo’98 planning stages.
Based on Expo’98 project strategies, identified
axes and zoning have been put forward for
planning as a method and have been adapted to
redevelop the region. Besides these, the criteria
identified for Varosha project based on Expo’98
have been listed in Table 3.
Table 3.
Criteria for Varosha Project based on Expo’98 Project Observations
Varosha Project Criteria
1. Reconstruction activities within the concept of universal design (Social Values) - Transportation: pedestrian and vehicle transportation - Circulation: within the town, town centre and others - Accessibility: Town centre and functions within the town
2. Form-function relationship -Horizontal-vertical structures -Usage of different functions together (residential-commercial and similar others)
3. Choosing the material for reconstruction activities (Economic Values) - Existing materials (Town centre and materials of surrounding buildings) - Modern materials
4. User Needs - Previous user needs - New user needs
5. Design proposals which can self-finance
6. Designs that are environmentally compatible (outdoor, semi-open and indoor space relations)
Within the light of these, the method which
emerged has been adapted to Varosha.
Implementing Expo’98 planning stages to
Varosha
As a result of observations and research of
Expo’98 on Lisbon city, project strategies
identified for Tagus Riverbank have been
adapted to Varosha. These strategies have been
determined based on two important aims. The
first aim is that the designed region can self-
finance its inactive fields, and the second one is
that the region can revive compatibly with its
environment. These strategies are presented in
Table 4.
244
www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
Table 4.
Project Strategies Suggested for Varosha
Project Strategies Suggested for Varosha
(1)Planning Stage
(2) Design Stage
(3) Development, Management and
Financial Stage
Planning work has been started
considering both before and after
1974. Aim: To create a hub and to re-
functionalise Varosha so it
becomes a commercial and
tourism centre. Pillars; -To enable diversified utilisation
(residential, service areas and
commercial units) -To arrange economic resources -To develop the strategic
infrastructure
To design Architectural Design:
new structures in place of
abandoned, unused buildings
To design new Urban Design:
buildings which are compatible
with existing town centre texture
with the idea of permanency and
functionality.
To Model Development/Management:
establish private companies with
responsibilities to purchase, develop
and sell regional land with access to
public funding.
Once the project is Financial Model:
completed, to enable its lease or sale
to investors or developers.
(Adopted from Aelbrecht, 2014)
In line with data on table 4, the first aim at the
planning stage is to consider different
transportation strategies to the region and to plan
national and international transportation access.
The second aim is to enable diversified usage.
Within this framework, besides balanced
distribution of facilities for central, commercial,
business, entertainment and cultural activities the
northeast and east of Varosha have been
allocated dominantly for residential purposes. To
enable diversified usage, a single hub for tram
and bus transportation has been considered. In
addition to this, semi-open, indoor and outdoor
art centre, one Mediterranean aquarium, multi-
functional pavilion, various public spaces and
parks have been considered with different
functions. With this transformation and
reconstruction project, Varosha region which has
been abandoned can be made available for public
usage once again.
Approximately 450 hectares of land which would
be used at planning, has been divided into six
main zones; 1. Central Zone, 2. Diversified
Usage Zone, 3. South-East Zone Protection
Zone (protected zone which is home for endemic
fauna and flora) 4. North-West Zone
Integration Zone with Historical Texture and
Port, 5. West Zone West of Varosha and
Integration Zone with South Cyprus and 6. Shore
Zone Pedestrian zone.
Table 5.
Zoning Plan for Varosha
VAROSHA ZONING PLAN
ZONE NAMES
SCOPE
(1)Central Zone
Indoor, outdoor and semi-open arts centre,
parks, town square, places for social and public
activities.
(2)Diversified Usage
Zone
The zone which has touristic, residential,
commercial and administrative building.
(3)South-East Zone
Protected Zone which is considered as national
park area with endemic fauna and flora.
(4)North-West Zone
This zone consists of residential, entertainment
and commercial areas and it integrates with
historical texture and the port.
(5)West Zone
This is an integration zone to West of Varosha
and South Cyprus. Bus and tram station is
planned for this zone.
(6) Shore Zone
This is a pedestrian zone. It consists of
touristic, commercial, entertainment places
(hotels, bars, clubs, restaurants, pedestrian
paths and cycling lanes).
Volume 11 - Issue 60
/ December 2022
245
http:// www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
As in the case of Expo’98, when new planning
criteria were applied, the main axes have been
identified. To enable interconnecting access to
zones and to support the workability of the
transportation-movement-access hub of the
zones presented in table 5, four main axes have
been identified. These are labelled as the main
axis, secondary axis, leisure axis and public axis.
As the primary axis, the main axis enables the
accessibility of neighbouring zones and connects
pedestrian and traffic to the town centre.
Secondary axis is a traffic and pedestrian axis
which functions as a backbone that connects
areas (residential and public spaces) to each
other. Leisure axis is a pedestrian axis which lays
along the whole seashore. Vertical to the sea,
public axis, integrates West of Varosha and the
seashore where it consists of main public
facilities such as shopping mall and the town
square. The transportation station is located at the
junction of the main axis and public axis (Figure
8).
Figure 8. Planning Axis Identified for Varosha
In the light of these studies, planning strategies,
zoning criteria and identified axes for Expo’98
have been adapted to Varosha.
Discussion
This section provides an assessment and
discussion on the criteria that was taken into
account regarding the stages of project strategies
as well as zoning and axes which have been
identified during planning for Varosha. Firstly, in
the assessment, a table has been created to cross-
check the project strategies and project criteria
for Varosha (Table 6). With this cross-check, the
connection between the project criteria and
strategies have been employed for the evaluation
of the zones which were identified as part of
Varosha reconstruction project.
246
www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
Table 6.
Cross-Check of Project Criteria and Strategies
PROJECT CRITERIA
PROJECT STRATEGIES
(1)Planning
Stage
(2)Design Stage
(3) Development,
Management and
Financial Stages
1. Reconstruction activities within the concept of
universal design (Social Values) -Transportation: yaya ulaşımı ve araç ulaşımı -Circulation: within the town, town centre and others Accessibility: Town centre and functions within the
town
2. Form-function relationship -Horizontal-vertical structures Usage of different functions together (residential-
commercial and similar others)
3. Choosing the material for reconstruction activities
(Economic Values) -Existing materials (Town centre and materials of
surrounding buildings) -Modern materials
4. User Needs -Previous user needs -New user needs
5. Design proposals which can self-finance
6. Designs that are environmentally compatible
(outdoor, semi-open and indoor space relations)
Before initiating the planning and design stage
(architectural and urban design), previous user
needs have been taken into consideration and
new user needs have been identified. Attention
has been paid to plan and to create
environmentally compatible designs and has
outdoor, semi-open and indoor space relations.
Furthermore, transportation, circulation and
accessibility have been considered in line with
the concept of universal design. Importance has
been given to interconnectedness of town, its
centre and main transportation stations (airport
and seaport). The utilisation of different building
heights enables the region to develop in a
balanced way both horizontally and vertically.
This approach provides an opportunity for
individuals with different income levels to live in
the same neighbourhood. The material for the
reconstruction areas have been chosen based on
the consideration of existing construction
materials (dominantly concrete), financial
availability and international commercial
agreements, and prioritising the use of new
materials. While zones are designed, it is
recommended that self-financing designs are
created. At planning and designing stages,
designers have taken into consideration that the
project is beneficial to everyone, it addresses user
needs, that it is in harmony with the existing town
texture and it is economical. On the other hand,
at development, management and financial
stages, it is the potentially financing private
companies and public institutions which are
responsible for the implementation and the
ability of self-financing of the project.
In conclusion, any project that is planned and
designed is expected to have the capability of
self-financing, addressing all stakeholders’ needs
and is accessible by all. When the particular
project of Varosha is considered as a whole, this
reconstruction project is crucial to regain its
popularity and its touristic and commercial status
in the international arena.
Conclusion
Besides residential areas and greenfield, cities
also have abandoned areas and Varosha is one of
the examples. In this study, a reconstruction
project was proposed for Varosha town which
has recently become a hot debate topic once
more. Reconstruction of abandoned areas is a
trending topic. This study emphases the
importance of identifying the project strategies
and criteria, and their joint-consideration before
any project is started on abandoned areas.
Therefore, the following diagram has been
created (Figure 9).
Volume 11 - Issue 60
/ December 2022
247
http:// www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
Figure 9. Project scheme for rehabilitation work on abandoned areas
The scheme which has been created as part of this
study has been adapted to Varosha region.
According to the scheme, before any project
work is initiated, strategies and criteria should be
identified. This strategy and criteria can be
applied to other abandoned areas, should there be
a relevant project. With this usage, the confusion
that designers experience is expected to be
eliminated in terms of creating self-financing
designs, old-new usage relationships, material
selection, form-function relationship, user needs,
transportation-circulation-accessibility which are
main problems that a designer faces before the
rehabilitation of these type of areas. This study is
expected to contribute to the project team who
would work in the reconstruction of Varosha as
well as architects, engineers, urban planners,
financers, researchers, public institutions that are
interested in this type of rehabilitation work.
This study is a revised and updated version of a
conference paper which was orally presented at
3rd Çukurova International Scientific Research
Congress.
Bibliographic references
Akansu, V. (2016). Has been retrieved by the
author from Expo’98 photo archive.
Akansu, V. (2020). Has been retrieved by the
author photo album.
Aelbrecht, P. S. (2014). A world fair for the
future: a study of the legacy of the expo'98
urban model. In meet me at the Fair: A
World's Fair Reader (pp. 485-501). [File
PDF]
Akengin H., & Kaykı, A. (2013). An example of
the relationship between urbanization and
university: Famagusta. Marmara Journal of
Geography, 28(501-525). (In Turkey)
Benhamou, F. (2019). Lisbon Expo'98: a major
event that has redesigned the city. Espaces,
Tourisme & Loisirs, 350, 32-37.
Bjorkdahl, A. Ve., & Kappler, S. (2017).
Peacebuilding and Spatial Transformation:
Peace, Space and Place. 32-51, London:
Routledge.
Boğaç, C. (2002). Adaptation and Place
Attachment in a Physically Foreign
Settlement: A Study of A Local Environment
in Aşağı Maraş, Gazimağusa. (Master thesis)
Eastern Mediterranean University, 7-15.
Boğaç, C. (2020). The process of developing an
emotional nexus between the self and an
uncanny geography: An autoethnography.
Emotion, Space and Society, 36, 100688.
Bueno-Lacy, R., & van Houtum, H. V. (2018).
The Glocal Green Line: The Imperial
Cartopolitical Puppeteering of Cyprus.
Geopolitics, 24(3), 586-624, Routledge
Taylor & Francis Group.
Christodoulou, N. (2016). The Role of Planning
in Ethno-Nationally Contested Cities: The
Case of Famagusta. University of Nicosia
(Unpublished PhD thesis). Nicosia-Cyprus.
Available
online: https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2
016/9/12/how-a-ghost-town-embodies-the-
cypriot-divide (accessed on 12 September
2021).
Cobham, C. D. (1969). Experta Cypria. Nicosia
Library. p. 254.
Delipetrou, P., Makhezoumi, J., Dimopoulos, P.
& Georghiou, K. (2008). Cyprus in:
Vogiatzakis, I., Pungetti, G., Mannion, A. M.
(Eds.), Mediterranean Island Landscapes,
Natural and Cultural Approaches. Berlin:
Springer, 170-219.
Detay. (2019). The Story of the Ghost Town;
“Marash”.
http://www.detaykibris.com/hayalet-sehrin-
PROJECT
CRITERIA
PROJECT
STRATEGIES
PLANNING
DESIGN
FINANCE
248
www.amazoniainvestiga.info ISSN 2322- 6307
hikayesi-maras-10g-p9.htm (Accessed on: 28
August 2019).
Dover & Partners Town Planning. (1998).
Brained Town Center: Plan & Design
Guidelines. Gibbs Planning Group, Inc.
Economic & Retail Planning. Glatting
Jackson Kercher Anglin Lopez Reinhart Inc.
Transportation Planning, Chattanooga,
Tennessee.
Feronti, S.M. (2003). ‘Greyfield Redevelopment
for community Revitalization: An
Explorationof Applications’. (Unpublished
Post Graduate Thesis) University of Florida.
Google Earth (2019). Website.
https://earth.google.com (Accessed on 19
August 2019)
Instituto Camões-Parque Expo98 (2000) Expo
98 Historian De Um Territorio Reinventado,
Joao Paula Veles, 2000. (Accessed on 06
August 2019)
Mustafa Mutlu İbili İbil, M. M. (2011). Covered
Varosha ... Varosha ... Ammochostos...
http://www.mutluibili.com.tr/default.asp?q=
14&h=71&l=2, (Accessed on: 21.08.2019).
Kapalı Maraş Çocukları. (2019). Website.
https://www.facebook.com/search/top/?q=ka
pali%20mara%C5%9F%20%C3%A7ocukla
ri&epa=SEARCH_BOX (Accessed on:
27.08.2019).
Kaypak, Ş. (2012). Developments in Coastal and
Urban Relations and Port Cities (Iskenderun
Port City Example. Turkey's Coastal and
Marine Areas IX National Congress 14-17
November 2012. Antakya-Hatay. (In Turkey)
Keshisian, K. K. (1985). Famagusta Town and
District Cyprus. Nicosia: Zavallis Press.
Michael, M. S. (2011). Resolving the Cyprus
Conflict: Negotiating History. New York: St.
Martin’s Press LLC.
Monclús, F. J. (2009). International Exhibitions
and Urbanism: The Zaragoza Expo 2008
Project. p.93. England: Ashgate Publications.
Önal, Ş., Dağlı, U., & Doratlı, N. (1999). The
urban problems of Gazimagusa (Famagusta)
and proposals for the future. Cities, 16(5)
333-351.
Pyla, P., & Phokaides, P. (2020). “Dark and
Dirty” Histories of Leisure and Architecture:
Varosha’s Past and Future. Architectural
Theory Review, 1-19.
Rafiemanzelat, R. (2014). A study on the
development of Liveable City Centres: The
Case of Famagusta, North Cyprus. (Master
Thesis). Eastern Mediterranean University.
Famagusta.
Randolph, B., & Freestone, R. (2008). Problems
and prospects for suburban renewal: an
Australian perspective. Sydney: City Future
Research Centre, University of New South
Wales, Research Paper, 11, Sydney.
Sterling, C. (2014). Spectral Anatomies:
Heritage, Hauntology and the ‘Ghosts’ of
Varosha. Present Pasts, 6(1), p. Art. 1. DOI:
http://doi.org/10.5334/pp.57
Swyngedouw, E., Moulaert, F., & Rodriguez, A.
(2002). Neoliberal Urbanization in Europe:
Large-Scale Urban Development Projects
and the New Urban Policy. Antipode,
547-582. Blackwell Publishing, USA.